Skip to main content
. 2007 Jul 18;2007(3):CD000270. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD000270.pub2
Study Reason for exclusion
Audini 1994 Allocation: randomised.
 Participants: people with serious mental illness.
 Intervention: assertive community treatment versus standard care.
Bedell 1989 Allocation: not randomised, matched controls.
Bond 1988 Allocation: randomised.
 Participants: people with serious mental illness.
 Intervention: assertive community treatment versus standard care.
Bond 1990 Allocation: randomised.
 Participants: people with serious mental illness.
 Intervention: assertive community treatment versus 'drop in' centre.
Cannon 1985 Allocation: randomised.
 Participants: people with schizophrenia.
 Intervention: hospital care versus residential programme.
Coelho 1993 Allocation: randomised.
 Participants: people with mild to moderate developmental disability, together with a DSM III diagnosis of mental illness.
 Interventions: intensive case management versus standard care.
Connolly 1996 Allocation: not randomised.
Crosby 1993 Allocation: not randomised.
Cuffel 1994 Allocation: not randomised.
Curtis 1998 Allocation: randomised.
 Participants: people discharged from an inpatient psychiatry service.
 Intervention: case management, not CMHT.
De‐Cangas 1995 Allocation: randomised.
 Participants: people with serious mental illness.
 Interventions: assertive community treatment versus standard care.
Dean 1993 Allocation: not randomised.
Dick 1991 Allocation: randomised.
 Participants: people with severe depression or anxiety.
 Intervention: day hospital versus out patient treatment.
Dixon 1997 Allocation: randomised.
 Participants: people with mental illnesses.
 Intervention assertive community treatment, not CMHT.
Essock 1995 Allocation: randomised.
 Participants: people with serious mental illness.
 Interventions: assertive community treatment versus case management.
Fenton 1979 Allocation: randomised.
 Participants: people with serious mental illness.
 Interventions: crisis intervention versus standard hospital care.
Ferguson 1992 Allocation: not randomised, case control study.
Ford 1995 Allocation: randomised.
 Participants: people with severe mental illness.
 Intervention: intensive case management versus standard care.
Franklin 1987 Allocation: randomised.
 Participants: people with chronic mental illness.
 Interventions: case management versus standard care.
Friedman 1964 Allocation: not randomised, series of preliminary project reports
Griffiths 1974 Allocation: randomised.
 Participants: people with psychotic illness and work problems.
 Interventions: rehabilitation unit versus standard care.
Hargreaves 2006 Allocation: unclear.
 Participants: people with severe mental illness.
 Intervention assertive community treatment, not CMHT
Harrison‐Read 2002 Allocation: randomised.
 Participants: people with serious mental illness and heavy service users.
 Interventions: enhanced case management/assertive community treatment versus standard CMHT care.
Heitger 1995 Allocation: not randomised.
Hoult 1981 Allocation: randomised.
 Participants: serious mental illness.
 Interventions: crisis intervention versus standard hospital care.
Huf 2002 Allocation: randomised.
 Participants: people with mental illnesses requiring IMI.
 Intervention: medication, not CMHT.
Husted 1994 Allocation: not randomised, repeated measures within subject design.
Jerrell 1995 Allocation: randomised.
 Participants: people with serious mental illness.
 Intervention: intensive case management versus program of assertive treatment versus standard CMHT.
Kluiter 1990 Allocation: randomised.
 Participants: people with serious mental illness.
 Interventions: day hospital versus standard care.
Knapp 1994 Allocation: randomised.
 Participants: people with serious mental illness. 
 Intervention: assertive community treatment.
Kovess 1988 Allocation: not randomised.
Krupinski 1984 Allocation: not randomised.
Kuldau 1977 Allocation: randomised.
 Participants: people with mental illness.
 Interventions: therapeutic community type approach versus rapid discharge with pre‐discharge planning (both inpatient treatment programmes).
Kwakwa 1995 Allocation: not randomised.
Lafave 1996 Allocation: randomised.
 Participants: people with mental illness.
 Interventions: assertive community treatment versus hospital based care.
Leff 1996 Allocation: not randomised.
Linn 1977 Allocation: randomised.
 Participants: people with mental illness.
 Interventions: foster care preparation and placement versus continued hospitalisation.
Linszen 2001 Allocation: unclear.
 Participants: people with first episode schizophrenia.
 Intervention: two forms of psychosocial interventions with medication.
Littrell 1995 Allocation: not randomised.
Locker 1984 Allocation: not randomised, case control design.
Macias 1994 Allocation: randomised.
 Participants: people with serious mental illness.
 Interventions: case management and psychosocial rehabilitation versus psychosocial rehabilitation.
Marks 1994 Allocation: randomised.
 Participants: people with serious mental illness.
 Interventions: assertive community treatment versus hospital based care.
Marshall 1995 Allocation: randomised.
 Participants: people with serious mental illness.
 Intervention: case management versus standard care.
McClary 1989 Allocation: not randomised.
McCrone 1994 Allocation: randomised.
 Participants: people with serious mental illness.
 Interventions: community intensive support team versus generic CPN care.
Modcrin 1988 Allocation: randomised.
 Participants: people with chronic mental illness.
 Interventions: developmental aquisition model of case management versus standard case management.
Muijen 1992a Allocation: randomised.
 Participants: people with serious mental illness. 
 Interventions: assertive community treatment versus standard care.
Muijen 1992b Allocation: randomised.
 Participants: people with serious mental illness.
 Interventions: assertive community treatment versus standard care.
Muijen 1994 Allocation: randomised.
 Participants: people with serious mental illness.
 Intervention: intensive CPN support versus generic CPN care.
Nordentoft 2002 Allocation: randomised.
 Participants: people with a first diagnosis of schizophrenia.
 Intervention: modified assertive community treatment.
Pasamanick 1964 Allocation: randomised.
 Participants: people with schizophrenia.
 Intervention: drugs versus placebo, with home care.
Paykel 1982 Allocation: randomised.
 Participants: people with serious mental illness.
 Interventions: CPN care versus standard out patient care.
Piper 1993 Allocation: randomised.
 Participants: people with mental illnesses.
 Interventions: day treatment versus no treatment, not CMHT.
Polak 1976 Allocation: randomised.
 Participants: people requiring psychiatric hospitalisation.
 Interventions: community based therapeutic environments versus standard hospital care.
Power 2002 Allocation: randomised.
 Participants: people with early psychosis.
 Interventions: assertive community treatment versus standard care.
Quinlivin 1995 Allocation: randomised.
 Participants: serious mental illness.
 Interventions: intensive case management versus traditional case management versus standard care.
Rosenheck 1995 Allocation: randomised.
 Participants: people with a mental illness.
 Interventions: intensive psychiatric community care versus standard care.
Ruphan 1992 Allocation: randomised.
 Participants: people with serious mental illness.
 Interventions: day hospital treatment versus standard care.
Rushton 1990 Allocation: not randomised, review.
Sands 1994 Allocation: not randomised, case control study.
Santiago 1985 Allocation:randomised.
 Participants: people with a major mental illness.
 Interventions: treatment network team versus standard care (inpatient and CMHT).
Schene 1993 Allocation: randomised.
 Participants: people referred for inpatient treatment.
 Interventions: day treatment versus inpatient care.
Sellwood 1999 Allocation: randomised.
 Participants: people with schizophrenia.
 Interventions: outpatient rehabilitation versus home based rehabilitation, not CMHT.
Slavinsky 1982 Allocation: randomised.
 Participants: people receiving long term psychiatric care.
 Interventions: nurse lead social support programme versus medication. clinics.
Smith 1974 Allocation: not randomised, matched pairs design.
Smith 1975 Allocation: not randomised.
Solomon 1994 Allocation: randomised.
 Participants: people with serious mental illness.
 Interventions: assertive community treatment versus intensive case management versus standard care.
Solomon 1995a Allocation: randomised.
 Participants: people with major mental illness.
 Interventions: consumer case management versus professional case management.
Solomon 1995b Allocation: randomised.
 Participants: people with severe mental illness.
 Interventions: assertive community treatment versus forensic intensive case management versus standard care.
Solomon 1995c Allocation: randomised.
 Participants: major mental illness diagnosis.
 Interventions: consumer case management versus professional case management.
Stein 1975 Allocation: randomised.
 Participants: people with chronic mental illness.
 Interventions: training in community living case versus standard care.
Tyrer 1995 Allocation: randomised.
 Participants: people with vulnerable psychiatric patients.
 Interventions: care programming approach versus standard follow up.
vanMinnen 1997 Allocation: randomised.
 Participants: people with mental retardation and mental illness.
 Intervention: assertive community treatment versus hospital care.
Walsh 2001 Allocation: randomised.
 Participants: people with established psychotic illness.
 Intervention: intensive case management versus standard case management.
Wiersma 1991 Allocation: randomised.
 Participants: people with schizophrenia.
 Interventions: specialised day centre versus hospital care.
Wilkinson 1995 Allocation: not randomised, cohort study.
Wirshing 2001 Allocation: randomised.
 Participants: people with schizophrenia.
 Interventions: two types of psycho‐education programmes.
Wood 1995 Allocation: not randomised, matched group design.
Zhang 1994 Allocation: not randomised, case control study.
Zimmer 1985 Allocation: randomised.
 Participants: elderly chronically ill / terminally ill.

ACT‐ Assertive Community Treatment
 CPN ‐ Community Psychiatric Nurse.
 CMHT‐ community mental health team.
 IMI‐ intramusular medication injection.