Skip to main content
. 2007 Jun 28;13(24):3316–3322. doi: 10.3748/wjg.v13.i24.3316

Table 1.

Various endoscopic therapeutic procedures for the treatment of SMTs

Indication Contraindications1 Complications Advantages Disadvantages
SSP[1,56] SMT < 2 cm; polypoid/pedunculated; sessile with a base < 1-2 cm; intraluminal and originating in muscularis mucosa or submucosa SMT > 2 cm; originating from the muscularis propria; intramural SMT; extraluminal SMT; located on the lesser curvature, posterior aspect of the stomach body or the cardia Incomplete resection, hemorrhage, perforation (when the SMT is > 2.5 cm) High success rate, few complications See "Complications"
SB[1,9,10,57,58] Same as for SSP Same as for SSP Minor bleeding treated with saline inj., metal clips or liquid thrombin The saline injection prevents full-thickness burning and perforation; high success rate; safe, quick and easy method If the saline is injected in the surrounding tissue, the SMT will become sessile and therefore more difficult to remove
ESMR-L[1] SMT < 1 cm SMT > 1 cm; originating from the muscularis propria No serious complications have been reported Not restricted by the location of the SMT; achieves deeper resection than SB and conventional EMR and thus a higher rate of curative resection This technique can only be applied to small SMTs
ESMR-C[1] SMT < 2 cm SMT > 2 cm; SMTs in the muscularis propria Minor hemorrhage, though rare. Simpler and easier version of EMR; high success rate; saline inj., see SB See "Complications"
UT[1,58] Simple and multicystic SMTs (e.g. lipomas and cystic lymphangiomas) Vascular tumors Hemorrhage Reduced risk of perforation, due to the fact that only the upper half is removed; can be applied to larger tumors Only applicable in cases of lipomas and cystic lymphangiomas
EE-M[1] Easiest if well capsulated; large SMTs and SMTs in the muscularis propria can be removed by this technique SMTs with wide bases, severe adhesions or not well capsulated Minor hemorrhage Can be used to resect leiomyomas originating from the muscularis propria; sessile or large SMTs > 2 cm can be resected Very difficult to perform
EE-I[1] Large SMTs and SMTs in the muscularis propria can be removed by this technique Unknown since this is a new technique Perforation, minor hemorrhage Like EE-M this technique is not limited by the size, sessile form or association with the muscularis propria New method, which means that the efficacy and safety is not known for sure
1

These are not absolute contraindications, but should rather be seen as circumstances, where resection is complicated. SSP: standard snare polypectomy; SB: strip biopsy; ESMR-L: resection performed with a ligation device; ESMR-C: endoscopic submucosal tumor resection with a transparent cap; UT: unroofing technique; EE-M: endoscopic enucleation performed with an initial mucosectomy; EE-I: endoscopic enucleation performed with an insulated-tip electrosurgical knife.