Table 1.
Indication | Contraindications1 | Complications | Advantages | Disadvantages | |
SSP[1,56] | SMT < 2 cm; polypoid/pedunculated; sessile with a base < 1-2 cm; intraluminal and originating in muscularis mucosa or submucosa | SMT > 2 cm; originating from the muscularis propria; intramural SMT; extraluminal SMT; located on the lesser curvature, posterior aspect of the stomach body or the cardia | Incomplete resection, hemorrhage, perforation (when the SMT is > 2.5 cm) | High success rate, few complications | See "Complications" |
SB[1,9,10,57,58] | Same as for SSP | Same as for SSP | Minor bleeding treated with saline inj., metal clips or liquid thrombin | The saline injection prevents full-thickness burning and perforation; high success rate; safe, quick and easy method | If the saline is injected in the surrounding tissue, the SMT will become sessile and therefore more difficult to remove |
ESMR-L[1] | SMT < 1 cm | SMT > 1 cm; originating from the muscularis propria | No serious complications have been reported | Not restricted by the location of the SMT; achieves deeper resection than SB and conventional EMR and thus a higher rate of curative resection | This technique can only be applied to small SMTs |
ESMR-C[1] | SMT < 2 cm | SMT > 2 cm; SMTs in the muscularis propria | Minor hemorrhage, though rare. | Simpler and easier version of EMR; high success rate; saline inj., see SB | See "Complications" |
UT[1,58] | Simple and multicystic SMTs (e.g. lipomas and cystic lymphangiomas) | Vascular tumors | Hemorrhage | Reduced risk of perforation, due to the fact that only the upper half is removed; can be applied to larger tumors | Only applicable in cases of lipomas and cystic lymphangiomas |
EE-M[1] | Easiest if well capsulated; large SMTs and SMTs in the muscularis propria can be removed by this technique | SMTs with wide bases, severe adhesions or not well capsulated | Minor hemorrhage | Can be used to resect leiomyomas originating from the muscularis propria; sessile or large SMTs > 2 cm can be resected | Very difficult to perform |
EE-I[1] | Large SMTs and SMTs in the muscularis propria can be removed by this technique | Unknown since this is a new technique | Perforation, minor hemorrhage | Like EE-M this technique is not limited by the size, sessile form or association with the muscularis propria | New method, which means that the efficacy and safety is not known for sure |
These are not absolute contraindications, but should rather be seen as circumstances, where resection is complicated. SSP: standard snare polypectomy; SB: strip biopsy; ESMR-L: resection performed with a ligation device; ESMR-C: endoscopic submucosal tumor resection with a transparent cap; UT: unroofing technique; EE-M: endoscopic enucleation performed with an initial mucosectomy; EE-I: endoscopic enucleation performed with an insulated-tip electrosurgical knife.