Skip to main content
. 2014 Aug 4;14(8):14106–14130. doi: 10.3390/s140814106

Table 2.

Comparison of the number of activations m of the TM phase and the number of evaluated points S{Pe} among the proposed algorithm and the reference ones, ATT (automatic target tracking) [17] and and PATT (predictive automatic target tracking) [18]. O, OTCBVS dataset; A, AMCOM dataset; AI, AIC dataset; RATT, relevance-based ATT.

Dataset ATT [17] PATT [18] RATT Δ ATT [17] Δ PATT [18]




Seq. L STW m S{Pe} m S{Pe} m S{Pe} S{Pe}% S{Pe}%
O 03-l1s1ir-1 154 16 × 30 41 44,649 23 25,047 60 846 1.89% 3.38%
O 03-l1s1ir-2 637 7 × 15 4 4,356 4 4,356 F F - -
O 03-l1s2ir-1 557 10 × 22 27 29,403 16 17,424 69 648 2.20% 3.72%
O 03-l1s2ir-2 339 10 × 20 112 121,968 92 100,188 105 635 0.52% 0.63%
O 03-l1s2ir-3 96 9x 18 11 11,979 4 4,356 45 1,548 12.92% 35.54%
O 03-l1s2ir-4 24 12 × 30 0 0 0 0 8 18 >100% >100%
O 03-l1s3ir-1 84 11 × 24 31 33,759 29 31,581 37 238 0.70% 0.75%
O 03-l1s3ir-2 787 8x 15 33 35,937 0 0 83 373 1.04% >100%
O 03-l1s3ir-3 448 10 × 24 4 4,356 40 43,560 6 26 0.60% 0.06%
O 03-l2s4ir-1 270 11 × 30 45 49,005 61 66,429 67 2,080 4.24% 3.13%
O 03-l2s6ir-1 323 15 × 28 8 8,712 124 135,036 200 1,382 15.86% 1.02%

A 14-15-mantruck 281 10 × 10 6 6,534 3 3,267 19 96 1.47% 2.94%
A 16-08-m60 290 13 × 7 60 65,340 18 19,602 32 2,788 4.27% 14.22%
A 16-08-apc 80 14 × 8 3 3,267 3 3,267 5 11 0.34% 0.34%
A 16-18-apc 300 11 × 8 15 16,335 1 1,089 29 161 0.99% 14.78%
A 16-18-m60 103 14 × 8 2 2,178 0 0 1 1 0.05% >100%
A 17-02-mantruck 221 9x 9 2 2,178 16 17,424 39 1,511 69.38% 8.67%
A 17-02-bradley 185 9x 9 5 5,445 9 9,801 6 132 2.42% 1.35%
A 18-13-m60 227 9x 9 25 27,225 8 8,712 34 550 2.02% 6.31%
A 18-16-m60 162 12 × 12 79 86,031 5 5,445 17 150 0.17% 2.75%
A 19-06-apc 208 10 × 10 6 6,534 7 7,623 41 367 5.62% 4.81%
A 21-17-apc 360 12 × 12 0 0 1 1,089 51 229 >100% 21.03%

AI ir11-1 263 21 × 40 93 180,048 110 212,960 147 8,789 4.88% 4.13%
AI ir11-2 155 25 × 37 101 195,536 109 211,024 103 2,993 1.53% 1.42%