Table 2.
Direction of Effects Reported for 6 Health Behaviors by Study (n=34).
Health Behavior | ||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Study | Physical activity | Nutrition | Sleep quality | Alcohol intake | Tobacco use | Body weight | ||
Type of study | # of waves | d | ||||||
Prospective longitudinal* | ||||||||
Avis et al., 1991bb | 2 | - | stablec | no change | stable | |||
Eng et al., 2005 a | 2 | .03, .25, .06, -, .50 | decreasedcd | worsened | increased | decreased | decreased | |
Janke et al., 2008a & 2008b | 2 | - | decreasede | |||||
Janke et al., 2008c b | 2 | .13 | increasedd | |||||
Lee et al., 2005 b | 2 | - | increasedc | worsened | increased | increased | decreased | |
Schulz et al., 2001 | 2 | .62, .50 | increasedcg | decreasedh | ||||
Shahar et al., 2001 | 2 | .97, 1.20 | worsened | decreased | ||||
Tran, 2007 | 2 | - | stablec | stable | ||||
Wilcox et al., 2003 b | 2 | .04, .19, .02, .02 | increasedc | worsened | decreased | decreased | ||
Williams, 2004 | 2 | - | ^ | ^ | ^ | ^ | ||
Postbereavement longitudinal* | ||||||||
Anderson, 1999 | 2 | 1.42 | declined | |||||
Byrne & Raphael, 1997 a | 3 | .48 | declined | |||||
Byrne et al., 1999 a | 3 | .43 | increased | |||||
Caserta et al., 2001 | 2 | .67 | decreasedc | |||||
Chen et al., 2005 | 2 | - | stablec | worsened | stable | |||
McIntyre & Howie, 2002 b | 3 | - | stabled | |||||
Monk et al., 2009 | 14 | 1.41 | declined | |||||
Nurriddin, 2008 | 3 | .08, .51, .28, .02 | decreasedc | worsened | increased | stable | ||
Pasternak et al., 1992 | 2 | 1.11 | declined | |||||
Quandt et al., 2000 | 5 | - | worsened | |||||
Reynolds III et al., 1992 | 3 | 1.27 | declined | |||||
Reynolds III et al., 1993 | 5 | .46 | stable | |||||
Wilcox & King, 2004 | 3 | .38 | decreasedbf |
Type of study | Control group | d | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Cross-sectional* | ||||||||
Barrett & Schneweis, 1980 | no | .34 | NR | |||||
Fitzpatrick et al., 2001 a | yes | .12 | no differencecd | |||||
Johnson, 2002 | yes | .92 | worsened | |||||
Okun et al., 2011 | yes | .15, .65, .01, - | decreasedc | declined | no difference | stable | ||
Patterson, 1996; Patterson & | no | - | decreasedc | |||||
Carpenter, 1994 | increasedd | |||||||
Rosenbloom & Whittington, 1993 | yes | 1.75, 1.60 | worsened | decreased | ||||
Schone & Weinick, 1998 | yes | .92,.73, .70 | decreasedc | worsened | increaseda | |||
Welte & Mirand, 1993 | yes | - | no difference | |||||
Wylie et al., 1999 | no | - | worsened |
NR=did not report results in reference to a control sample. Effect sizes were estimated for quantitative studies that reported means and standard deviations for outcome variables.
Results are reported for widowed elders across time.
Results are reported for widowed elders in reference to a control sample.
Did not report results that allowed for the estimation of effect sizes.
This study created a “health-risk” variable by summing 4 behavioral variables. Widowhood was associated with an increase in health-risk behaviors, but the effect of bereavement on each of these health behaviors was not reported.
Significant effect reported for widowed men only.
Significant effect reported for widowed women only.
Sports/exercise activity.
Leisure/social activity.
Physical activity and exercise only; elders increased their social activities across time.
Class-based exercise only; home-based exercise remained stable.
Among caregivers (who experienced strain) only.
Among noncaregivers only.