Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2014 Oct 15.
Published in final edited form as: J Behav Med. 2013 Jul 24;37(4):736–755. doi: 10.1007/s10865-013-9524-7

Table 2.

Direction of Effects Reported for 6 Health Behaviors by Study (n=34).

Health Behavior
Study Physical activity Nutrition Sleep quality Alcohol intake Tobacco use Body weight
Type of study # of waves d
Prospective longitudinal*
Avis et al., 1991bb 2 - stablec no change stable
Eng et al., 2005 a 2 .03, .25, .06, -, .50 decreasedcd worsened increased decreased decreased
Janke et al., 2008a & 2008b 2 - decreasede
Janke et al., 2008c b 2 .13 increasedd
Lee et al., 2005 b 2 - increasedc worsened increased increased decreased
Schulz et al., 2001 2 .62, .50 increasedcg decreasedh
Shahar et al., 2001 2 .97, 1.20 worsened decreased
Tran, 2007 2 - stablec stable
Wilcox et al., 2003 b 2 .04, .19, .02, .02 increasedc worsened decreased decreased
Williams, 2004 2 - ^ ^ ^ ^
Postbereavement longitudinal*
Anderson, 1999 2 1.42 declined
Byrne & Raphael, 1997 a 3 .48 declined
Byrne et al., 1999 a 3 .43 increased
Caserta et al., 2001 2 .67 decreasedc
Chen et al., 2005 2 - stablec worsened stable
McIntyre & Howie, 2002 b 3 - stabled
Monk et al., 2009 14 1.41 declined
Nurriddin, 2008 3 .08, .51, .28, .02 decreasedc worsened increased stable
Pasternak et al., 1992 2 1.11 declined
Quandt et al., 2000 5 - worsened
Reynolds III et al., 1992 3 1.27 declined
Reynolds III et al., 1993 5 .46 stable
Wilcox & King, 2004 3 .38 decreasedbf
Type of study Control group d
Cross-sectional*
Barrett & Schneweis, 1980 no .34 NR
Fitzpatrick et al., 2001 a yes .12 no differencecd
Johnson, 2002 yes .92 worsened
Okun et al., 2011 yes .15, .65, .01, - decreasedc declined no difference stable
Patterson, 1996; Patterson & no - decreasedc
Carpenter, 1994 increasedd
Rosenbloom & Whittington, 1993 yes 1.75, 1.60 worsened decreased
Schone & Weinick, 1998 yes .92,.73, .70 decreasedc worsened increaseda
Welte & Mirand, 1993 yes - no difference
Wylie et al., 1999 no - worsened

NR=did not report results in reference to a control sample. Effect sizes were estimated for quantitative studies that reported means and standard deviations for outcome variables.

*

Results are reported for widowed elders across time.

**

Results are reported for widowed elders in reference to a control sample.

-

Did not report results that allowed for the estimation of effect sizes.

^

This study created a “health-risk” variable by summing 4 behavioral variables. Widowhood was associated with an increase in health-risk behaviors, but the effect of bereavement on each of these health behaviors was not reported.

a

Significant effect reported for widowed men only.

b

Significant effect reported for widowed women only.

c

Sports/exercise activity.

d

Leisure/social activity.

e

Physical activity and exercise only; elders increased their social activities across time.

f

Class-based exercise only; home-based exercise remained stable.

g

Among caregivers (who experienced strain) only.

h

Among noncaregivers only.