Table 1. Study characteristics.
Reference | Country | Study design | age | Exposure pathway | biomarker | Biologic specimen | Cases/controls | OR or RR (95%CI) |
Arrebola2013 | Spain | Cross-sectional | 16- | Background | p,p′-DDE | Serum lipid | 34/352 | 1.69(0.54–5.22)a |
Wu2012 | USA | Prospective | 30–55 | Nurses | PCB-153 | Serum lipid | 10/214 | 2.19(0.72–6.68)a |
30–55 | Nurses | PCB-153 | Serum lipid | 6/135 | 0.76(0.22–2.60)a | |||
30–55 | Nurses | PCBs | Serum lipid | 9/215 | 1.30(0.43–3.93)a | |||
30–55 | Nurses | PCBs | Serum lipid | 7/134 | 0.79(0.23–2.71)a | |||
30–55 | Nurses | p,p′-DDE | Serum lipid | 9/215 | 1.32(0.41–4.27)a | |||
30–55 | Nurses | p,p′-DDE | Serum lipid | 10/131 | 1.79(0.54–5.86)a | |||
Persky2012 | USA | Cross-sectional | 35- | Electrical utilities company men | PCB-153 | Serum lipid | 7/56 | 3.1(1.2–7.8)a |
35- | Electrical utilities company men | PCBs | Serum lipid | 7/56 | 3.0(1.3–7.2)a | |||
Gasull2012 | Spain | Cross-sectional | 18–74 | Background | PCB-153 | Serum | 77/192 | 1.6(1.2–2.4)a |
18–74 | Background | PCBs | Serum | 77/193 | 1.7(1.1–2.6)a | |||
18–74 | Background | p,p′-DDE | Serum | 73/207 | 1.1(0.7–1.7)a | |||
Silverstone2012 | USA | Cross-sectional | 18- | PCBs plant area | PCBs | Serum | 78/157 | 2.78(1.00–7.73) |
18–55 | PCBs plant area | PCBs | Serum | 27/111 | 4.78(1.11–20.6) | |||
55- | PCBs plant area | PCBs | Serum | 51/47 | 4.19(0.26–68.12) | |||
Lee 2011 | Sweden | Prospective | 70 | background | PCB-153 | Serum | 12/277 | 1.7(0.5–6.2) |
70 | background | p,p′-DDE | Serum | 16/271 | 2.1(0.7–6.3) | |||
Airaksinen2011 | Finland | Cross-sectional | 70 | background | PCB-153 | Serum lipid | 69/398 | 1.64(0.92–2.93)b |
70 | background | PCB-153 | Serum lipid | 10/121 | 1.03(0.25–4.18)b | |||
70 | background | PCB-153 | Serum lipid | 23/184 | 1.97(0.75–5.23)b | |||
70 | background | PCB-153 | Serum lipid | 36/93 | 2.3(0.87–6.11)b | |||
70 | background | p,p′-DDE | Serum lipid | 62/398 | 1.75(0.96–3.19)b | |||
70 | background | p,p′-DDE | Serum lipid | 7/120 | 0.88(0.18–4.35)b | |||
70 | background | p,p′-DDE | Serum lipid | 18/175 | 1.91(0.69–5.27)b | |||
70 | background | p,p′-DDE | Serum lipid | 37/103 | 1.82(0.71–4.65)b | |||
Tanaka 2011 | Japan | Cross-sectional | 40–64 | background | PCB-153 | Serum | 32/85 | 0.95(0.90–1.00)a |
40–64 | background | PCB-153 | Serum lipid | 32/85 | 0.73(0.51–1.07) | |||
Grandjean2011 | Faroe Islands | Cross-sectional | 70–74 | Aquatic product | PCBs | Serum lipid | 168/544 | 1.11(0.91–1.35)a |
70–74 | Aquatic product | p,p′-DDE | Serum lipid | 168/544 | 1.01(0.87–1.16)a | |||
Son2010 | Korea | Cross-sectional | 40- | Background | p,p′-DDE | Serum | 27/26 | 26.6(2.0–349.1) |
40- | Background | p,p′-DDE | Serum lipid | 28/26 | 12.7(1.9–83.7) | |||
Everett2010 | USA | Cross-sectional | 20- | Background | p,p′-DDE | Serum lipid | 334/2715 | 1.08(0.58–2.03)a |
Ukropec2010 | Slovakia | Cross-sectional | 21–75 | Heavy pollution | PCBs | Serum lipid | 120/699 | 1.86(1.09–3.17) |
21–75 | Heavy pollution | p,p′-DDE | Serum lipid | 125/694 | 1.94(1.11–3.78) | |||
Lee2010 | USA | Perspective | 18–30 | Background | PCB-153 | Serum lipid | 39/45 | 0.8(0.2–2.6)a |
18–30 | Background | p,p′-DDE | Serum lipid | 47/45 | 0.7(0.2–1.9)a | |||
Philibert2009 | Canada | Cross-sectional | 15–86 | Aquatic product | PCB-153 | Serum | 25/101 | 4.91(1.27–19.01) |
15–86 | Aquatic product | PCB-153 | Serum lipid | 25/101 | 6.46(2.07–36.63) | |||
15–86 | Aquatic product | PCBs | Serum | 25/101 | 4.91(1.27–19.01) | |||
15–86 | Aquatic product | PCBs | Serum lipid | 25/101 | 5.51(1.26–24.07) | |||
15–86 | Aquatic product | p,p′-DDE | Serum | 25/101 | 6.11(1.37–27.3) | |||
15–86 | Aquatic product | p,p′-DDE | Serum lipid | 25/101 | 3.56(0.97–13.08) | |||
Rignell-Hydbom2009 | Sweden | Prospective | 50–59 | Background women | PCB-153 | Serum | 371/371 | 0.99(0.71–1.4)c |
50–59 | Background women | PCB-153 | Serum | 208/208 | 0.91(0.59–1.4)c | |||
50–59 | Background women | PCB-153 | Serum | 163/163 | 1.1(0.66–1.9)c | |||
50–59 | Background women | PCB-153 | Serum | 107/107 | 1.4(0.72–2.6)c | |||
50–59 | Background women | PCB-153 | Serum | 74/74 | 1.4(0.67–3.1)c | |||
50–59 | Background women | PCB-153 | Serum | 39/39 | 1.6(0.61–4.0)c | |||
50–59 | Background women | p,p′-DDE | Serum | 371/371 | 1.1(0.76–1.5)c | |||
50–59 | Background women | p,p′-DDE | Serum | 208/208 | 0.9(0.57–1.4)c | |||
50–59 | Background women | p,p′-DDE | Serum | 163/163 | 1.3(0.78–2.2)c | |||
50–59 | Background women | p,p′-DDE | Serum | 107/107 | 1.5(0.8–2.8)c | |||
50–59 | Background women | p,p′-DDE | Serum | 74/74 | 2.5(0.97–6.4)c | |||
50–59 | Background women | p,p′-DDE | Serum | 39/39 | 5.5(1.2–25)c | |||
Turyk2009 | USA | Prospective | 25–76 | Aquatic product | p,p′-DDE | Serum | 24/285 | 7.1(1.6–31.9) |
25–76 | Aquatic product | PCBs | Serum | 21/293 | 1.8(0.6–5.0) | |||
Wang2008 | Taiwan, China | Cross-sectional | 30- | Rice-bran oil men | PCBs | Serum | 155/152 | 1.7(0.7–4.6)a |
30- | Rice-bran oil women | PCBs | Serum | 233/218 | 5.5(2.3–13.4)a | |||
Codru2007 | USA | Cross-sectional | 30- | Background | PCBs | Serum | 2.8 (0.7–10.8)a | |
30- | Background | PCBs | Serum lipid | 2.6 (0.8–8.1)a | ||||
30- | Background | PCB-153 | Serum | 3.0 (0.7–12.8)a | ||||
30- | Background | PCB-153 | Serum lipid | 1.4 (0.4–4.8)a | ||||
30- | Background | p,p′-DDE | Serum | 2.6 (0.8–8.8)a | ||||
30- | Background | p,p′-DDE | Serum lipid | 2.4 (0.7–8.3)a | ||||
Rignell-Hydbom2007 | Sweden | Cross-sectional | 29–59 | Aquatic product women | PCB-153 | Serum lipid | 15/528 | 1.4(0.8–2.5)a |
29–59 | Aquatic product women | p,p′-DDE | Serum lipid | 15/528 | 1.3(1.1–1.5)a | |||
Cox2007 | USA | Cross-sectional | 20–74 | Background | p,p′-DDE | Serum | 45/768 | 2.63(1.2–5.8)a |
20–74 | Background | p,p′-DDE | Serum lipid | 35/560 | 1.5(0.8–2.9)a | |||
Lee2006 | USA | Cross-sectional | 12- | Background | PCB-153 | Serum lipid | 52/598 | 6.8(3.0–15.5) |
12- | Background | p,p′-DDE | Serum lipid | 69/704 | 4.3(1.8–10.2) | |||
Rylander2005 | Sweden | Cross-sectional | 49–84 | Aquatic product | PCB-153 | Serum lipid | 22/358 | 1.16(1.03–1.32) |
49–84 | Aquatic product | p,p′-DDE | Serum lipid | 22/358 | 1.05(1.01–1.09) | |||
Fierens2003 | Belgium | Case-control | 50.3–59.4 | Background | PCBs | Serum lipid | 9/248 | 7.6(1.58–36.3) |
Different models adjusted by confounding, such as sex, age, BMI, total cholesterol and triglycerides, and various compounds.
stratified by BMI.
stratified by the years diagnosed after the baseline investigation.