Skip to main content
. 2014 Jun 15;5:110–124. doi: 10.5116/ijme.5380.ca6b

Table 1. Gender differences in academic surgery.

Author Year Participants Type of study Study objective Findings
Cochran 2013 Senior surgical residents and early career surgical faculty members Survey To test the hypothesis than female surgeons perceive different barriers to academic careers relative to their male colleagues Women experience gender as a barrier to develop a career in academic surgery.
Sexton 2012 Member of American Association of Medical Colleges Cohort study To examined the trends for gender-based advancement in academic surgery The percentage of full professors in surgery who are women is increasing at a rate disproportionately slower than the increase in female medical students and surgery residents.
Prichard 2011 Non-consultant hospital doctors Survey To investigate differences in attitudes and practices of male and female junior doctors in the practice of undergraduate teaching. No significant differences between the genders regarding the self-reported quantity of teaching provided to undergraduates. Male and female doctors have similar attitudes toward, and practices in, voluntary undergraduate teaching.
Zhuge 2011 Review To analyze the factors that contribute to the glass ceiling phenomenon Traditional gender roles, manifestations of sexism in the medical environment, and lack of effective mentors make women advance more slowly than men in academic surgery.
Morton 2007 Women and men on a professional society or journal editorial board Survey To quantify the number of women in this boards Women's representation on societies and editorial boards does not always reflect their presence in medical specialties. 83% of board members were men, and occupied >80% of top leadership positions.
Hoover 2006 Editorial To identify factors behind gender inequities in academic surgery Underrepresentation of women at all levels of academic surgery; importance of mentoring.
Klingensmith 2006 Members of the Association for Surgical Education Cohort study To determine whether or not educational scholarship is a pathway to academic promotion Overrepresentation of male in academic surgery (82 vs 18%). Women seek advanced training in educational scholarship in greater proportions than men. Academic promotion occurs for individuals with focus on education.
Mendoza 2004 Members of the Association of Surgical Education and the Association of Program directors in Surgery Survey To assess academic preparation and scholarly activity of educators in surgical departments Professional educators provide support needed to meet the growing demands and requirements of surgical education. Predominance of women involved in education.
Risberg 2003 Physicians involved in medical teaching Prospective cohort To investigate gender awareness among physician teachers There is an interaction between physician teachers' gender and specialty. Male physicians from the surgical group assessed gender less important than female physicians in professional relationship. No significant differences between specialty groups among women.
Flannery 2002 Review Difficulties for women to progress in academic promotion. More women involved in clinical teaching.
Jonasson 2002 Members of several American surgical societies Cohort study To assess the status of women in leadership positions in surgery Underrepresentation of women in the major American societies and organizations, and in higher levels of academic departments of surgery.
Tesch 1995 American physician, AAMC database Survey To explain the fact that the percentage of women members of medical school faculty with professor rank is lower than men Women physician medical school faculty are promoted more slowly than equal qualified men.