Skip to main content
. 2014 Jul 15;7(4):178–192. doi: 10.1016/j.optom.2014.06.005

Table 2.

Methodological characteristics of 56 articles of the review.

Study
(Author, year of publication)
Patient characteristics Dysfunction Symptoms obtained
Borsting E, 201213 218 children. Age: 9–17 years CI CISS V-15 + Academic Behaviour Survey
Barnhardt C, 201214 221 children. Age: 9–17 years CI CISS V-15
Pang Y, 201215 29 subjects. Age: 45–68 years CI CISS V-15
Scheiman M, 201116 221 children. Age: 9–17 years CI + AI CISS V-15
Serna A, 201117 42 children. Age: 5–18 years CI Case History
Shin S, 201118 57 children. Age: 9–13 years CI + AI 19-Item COVD-QOL
Alvarez T, 201019 13 NBV subjects. Age: 21–35 years
4 CI subjects. Age: 20–26 years
CI CISS V-15
Scheiman M, 201020 221 children. Age: 9–17 years CI CISS V-15
Wahlberg M, 201021 22 children. Age: 7–17 years AI Case History
Shin S, 200922 1031 children. Age: 9–13 years AD + BD 19-Item COVD-QOL
Rouse M, 200923 102 NBV children. Age: 9–17 years
221 CI children. Age: 9–17 years
CI CISS V-15
Rouse M, 200924 212 children. Age: 9-17years CI Academic Behaviour Survey
Teitelbaum B, 200925 29 subjects. Age: 45–68 years CI CISS V-15
Kulp M, 200926 221 children. Age: 9–17 years CI CISS V-15
Cooper J, 2009 27 43 subjects. Age: 9–33 years AD + BD CISS V-15
Chase C, 200928 88 subjects. Age: 18–22 years AI Conlon Survey
CITT, 200929 79 children. Age: 9–17 years CI CISS V-15
Bartuccio M, 200830 504 subjects. Age: 6–27 years AI Case History
Brautaset R, 200831 24 children. Age: not specified
Mean age: 10.3 years
AI Case History
Borsting E, 200832 23 subjects. Age: not specified
Mean age: 19 years, 9 month
AD + BD Conlon Survey + 
CISS V-15
Kulp M, 200833 32 subjects. Age: 9–30 years CI CISS V-15
CITT, 2008a34 221 children. Age: 9–17 years CI CISS V-15
CITT, 2008b35 221 children. Age: 9–17 years CI CISS V-15 + Academic Behaviour Survey
Abdi S, 200736 12 children. Age: 8–16 children AI Case History
Borsting E, 200737 571 subjects. Age: 18–22 years AD + BD Conlon Survey
Bodack M, 200738 241 subjects. Age: 26–81 years AD + BD Case History
Aziz S, 200639 78 subjects. Age: 5–73 years BD Case History
Brautaset R, 200640 10 subjects. Age not specified
Mean age: 25.4 ± 4.1 years
CI Case History
Marran L, 20068 299 children. Age not specified
Mean age: 11.5 ± 0.63 years
AI CISS V-15
Sterner B, 200641 72 subjects. Age: 5.8–9.8 years AI Sterner Questionnaire
Vaughn W, 200642 91 children. Age not specified AD + BD 19-Item COVD-QOL
Abdi S, 20057 120 children. Age: 6–16 years CI + AI Case History
Scheiman M, 200543 47 children. Age: 9–18 years CI CISS V-15
Scheiman M, 200544 46 subjects. Age: 19–30 years CI CISS V-15
Scheiman M, 200545 72 children. Age: 9–18 years CI CISS V-15
Rouse M, 200446 46 CI subjects. Age: 19–30 years
46 NBV subjects. Age: 19–30 years
CI CISS V-15
White T, 200447 129 subjects. Age: 9–19 years CI 19- Item COVD-QOL
Borsting E, 20039 392 children. Age: 7.6–14.8 years CI CISS 16 Items
Borsting E, 200348 47 CI children. Age: 9–18 years
56 NBV children. Age: 9–18 years
CI CISS V-15
Adler P, 200249 92 subjects. Age: 5–35 years CI Adler Questionnaire
Cacho P, 200250 328 subjects. Age: 13–35 years AI Case History
Gallaway M, 200251 25 subjects. Age: 9–51 years CI Gallaway Questionnaire
Garcia A, 200252 69 subjects. Age: 13–35 years AD + BD Case History
Lara F, 200153 265 subjects. Age: 10–35 years AD + BD Case History
Borsting E, 199955 14 CI children. Age: 8–13 years
14 NBV children. Age: 8–13 years
CI CIRS Symptom Questionnaire Parent version
Birnbaum M, 199956 60 subjects. Age: >40 years CI Birnbaum Questionnaire
Rouse M, 199854 415 children. Age: 8–12 years CI Case History
Porcar E, 199757 65 subjects. Age not specified
Mean age: 22 ± 3 years
AD + BD Case History
Gallaway M, 199758 83 subjects. Age: 7–32 years CE Case History
Russell G, 199359 15 subjects. Age: 9–34 years AI Russell Questionnaire
Matsuo T, 199260 9 children. Age: 6–16 years AI + CI Case History
Dwyer, 199261 144 children. Age: 7–18 years AD + BD Case History
Deshpande S, 199162 2162 subjects. Age: 15–35 years CI Case History
Mazow T, 198963 26 subjects. Age: 7–28 years CI + AI Case History
Rutstein R, 198864 17 subjects. Age: 7–39 years AE Case History
Chrousos G, 198865 10 subjects. Age: 10–19 years AI Case History

CI: convergence insufficiency, AI: accommodative insufficiency, AD: accommodative dysfunction, BD: binocular dysfunction, CE: convergence excess, AE: accommodative excess, NBV: normal binocular vision.