Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2015 May 1.
Published in final edited form as: Health Behav Policy Rev. 2014 May;1(3):183–190. doi: 10.14485/HBPR.1.3.2

Table 2. Communication of Multiple Perspectives, Debate, Controversy and Potential Credibility Issues in News Articles.

Among all news/feature articles (N=677)
 Inclusion of at least one “Pro-SLT” message 17.3%
 Inclusion of at least one “Anti-SLT” message 28.7%
 Inclusion of at least one “Pro” and one “Anti” SLT message 12.2%
Among articles that included at least one Pro and Anti message (N=83)
 Reference to “debate” or “difference in views” regarding SLT 35.0%
Among articles referring to debate or “difference” in SLT views (N=29)
 Reference to differences as between health professionals 79.0%
 Reference to differences as between health professionals & tobacco companies 24.1%
 Reference to debate as being controversial or “moralistic”. 17.0%
Among articles that included at least one Pro message (N=117)
 Claims that the public is misled about SLT risks 8.5%
 Reference to research/researcher funded by SLT industry 7.7%