Skip to main content
. 2014 Nov 12;9(11):e112735. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0112735

Table 2. Cumulative probability of osteoarthritis progression according to mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) haplogroups and results of the extended Cox proportional hazard model.

KL grade JSN Osteophytes Subchondral sclerosis
Variables N(%Progressors)¥ HR 95% CI# N(%Progressors)¥ HR 95% CI# N(%Progressors)¥ HR 95% CI# N(%Progressors)¥ HR 95% CI#
Gender (male) 0.672 0.528–0.859* 1.006 0.755–1.335 0.843 0.650–1.081 1.021 0.791–1.343
Age (years) 1.011 0.999–1.024 0.998 0.982–1.013 0.993 0.980–1.007 1.008 0.994–1.023
BMI (Kg/m2) 1.045 1.020–1.069* 1.052 1.021–1.084* 1.028 1.004–1.055* 1.027 0.996–1.056
Previous surgery 0.909 0.702–1.190 0.686 0.487–0.909 0.981 0.739–1.282 1.054 0.788–1.378
Worst knee at bl± 0.937 0.687–1.305 4.993 3.700–7.373* 1.799 1.405–2.314* 1.396 1.050–1.827*
mtDNA haplogroups
H (n = 341) 145 (42.5%) 1 111 (32.6%) 1 164 (48.0%) 1 136 (39.8%) 1
J (n = 89) 40 (44.3%) 1.147 0.731–1.655 28 (31.4%) 0.891 0.581–1.404 45 (51.1%) 1.090 0.715–1.611 29 (32.5%) 0.764 0.487–1.230
Uk (n = 228) 100 (44.1%) 0.986 0.760–1.356 64 (28.4%) 0.741 0.530–1.049 106 (46.8%) 0.906 0.684–1.203 66 (29.1%) 0.632 0.436–0.879
T (n = 85) 19 (22.0%) 0.499 0.261–0.819* 17 (19.7%) 0.547 0.280–0.900* 25 (29.0%) 0.573 0.304–0.893* 21 (25.0%) 0.549 0.295–0.884*
Others (n = 148) 53 (36.0%) 0.786 0.542–1.099 35 (23.7%) 0.699 0.445–1.051 50 (34.1%) 0.687 0.500–1.013 52 (35.1%) 0.847 0.563–1.220

KL: Kellgren and Lawrence; JSN: joint space narrowing; BMI: body mass index; bl: baseline; (¥): cumulative osteoarthritis progression rate after 48 months of follow-up; HR: hazard ratio; CI: confidence interval; (#): confidence intervals for the hazard ratios obtained using the bootstrap methodology by the percentile method; (±): the worst knee at baseline refers to the radiological status of the knee attending to (highest) KL grade, JSN grade, osteophytes grade or sclerosis grade, as appropriate on each case; (*): statistical significance declared at p≤0.05.