Table 3. Comparison of mean quality score for each AGREE II domain by subgroup.
Subgroups | Domain(Mean ± SD) | |||||
Scope&Purpose | Stakeholders | Rigor | Clarity | Applicability | Editorial | |
Year of publications | ||||||
Pre-AGREE II(n = 10) | 65.00±9.82 | 44.44±18.33 | 39.48±25.80 | 61.34±13.76 | 31.24±18.76 | 28.33±24,27 |
Post-AGREE II(n = 7) | 57.14±20.90 | 46.03±22.90 | 45.09±31.71 | 67.06±18.10 | 30.95±22.84 | 32.14±33.22 |
p values | 0.35 | 0.88 | 0.7 | 0.48 | 0.98 | 0.8 |
MD,95%CI | 7.86 (−8.78, 24.49) | −1.59(−22.00,18.83) | −5.61(−34.03,22.81) | −5.67(−21.57,10.22) | 0.30(−20.23,20.83) | −3.81(−32.66,25.04) |
Performers | ||||||
NGC&AAN(n = 7) | 72.62±6.29 | 58.73±12.04 | 64.43±22.87 | 75.79±11.86 | 44.64±19.31 | 52.38±20.39 |
Others(n = 10) | 54.17±15.28 | 35.56±18.56 | 25.93±18.00 | 55.28±11.67 | 21.67±14.47 | 14.17±19.66 |
p values | 0.0006 | 0.002 | 0.0002 | 0.0004 | 0.008 | 0.0001 |
MD,95%CI | 18.45(7.89,29.01) | 23.17(8.62,37.73) | 38.50(18.21,58.78) | 20.52(9.13,31.90) | 22.98(6.09,39.86) | 38.21(18.81,57.62) |
EB CPGs | ||||||
Yes(n = 11) | 69.19±9.25 | 53.54±17.66 | 53.98±26.54 | 71.97±12.14 | 39.58±19.59 | 44.32±23.37 |
No(n = 6) | 48.15±15.28 | 29.63±12.99 | 19.44±9.81 | 48.61±6.51 | 15.63±6.81 | 3.47±3.14 |
p values | 0.002 | 0.001 | 0.0001 | <0.00001 | 0.0002 | <0.00001 |
MD,95%CI | 21.04 [7.65, 34.44] | 23.91(9.18,38.63) | 34.53(16.99,52.07) | 23.36(14.49,32.23) | 23.96(11.16,36.75) | 40.85(26.81,54.88) |
Notes: MD, mean difference; CI, Confidence interval; EB, evidence-based; CPGs, clinical practice guidelines; SD, standard deviation.