Skip to main content
. 2014 Nov 21;9(11):e113677. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0113677

Table 1. Simulation study: bias and root mean squared error (RMSE) of regression coefficients Inline graphic of a continuous exposure variable Inline graphic in unselected models, models selected by backward elimination (BE) and models selected by augmented backward elimination (ABE) for linear, logistic and Cox regression.

VIF Inline graphic Variable selection among Inline graphic Bias (×100) RMSE (×100) Selected models (%)
of Inline graphic Biased Correct Inflated
Linear regression
No selection 1 24 100
2 0 BE, Inline graphic 3 21 33 35 32
ABE, Inline graphic Inline graphic 2 22 28 34 38
No selection 1 24 100
2 1 BE, Inline graphic 3 21 33 35 32
ABE, Inline graphic 2 21 29 35 36
No selection 1 57 100
4 0 BE, Inline graphic 6 50 39 34 27
ABE, Inline graphic 2 56 25 14 61
No selection 1 57 100
4 1 BE, Inline graphic 6 50 40 34 27
ABE, Inline graphic 2 56 28 17 56
Logistic regression
No selection 1 20 100
2 0 BE, Inline graphic 1 17 7 48 45
ABE, Inline graphic 1 20 1 4 95
No selection 6 25 100
2 1 BE, Inline graphic 5 21 11 43 46
ABE, Inline graphic 6 25 2 3 95
No selection 2 47 100
4 0 BE, Inline graphicGeben Sie hier eine Formel ein. 4 38 12 46 42
ABE, Inline graphic 2 47 1 2 97
No selection 6 55 100
4 1 BE, Inline graphic 7 46 17 41 43
ABE, Inline graphic 6 55 1 1 98
Cox regression
No selection −1 22 100
2 0 BE, Inline graphicGeben Sie hier eine Formel ein. 1 19 20 40 40
ABE, Inline graphic −1 22 7 13 80
No selection 2 23 100
2 1 BE, Inline graphicGeben Sie hier eine Formel ein. 3 20 19 40 41
ABE, Inline graphic 2 23 7 13 80
No selection −2 52 100
4 0 BE, Inline graphic 4 47 26 36 38
ABE, Inline graphic −2 52 6 5 89
No selection 1 52 100
4 1 BE, Inline graphicGeben Sie hier eine Formel ein. 6 46 28 36 36
ABE, Inline graphic 1 52 7 4 89

Abbreviations and symbols: Inline graphic, significance threshold; ABE, augmented backward elimination; BE, backward elimination; RMSE, root mean squared error; Inline graphic, change-in-estimate threshold; VIF, variance inflation factor of Inline graphic conditional on Inline graphic. Sample size, Inline graphic subjects; Number of simulations, Inline graphic; Variables selection based on six continuous candidate adjustment variables Inline graphic, among which three are truly associated with the outcome and five are correlated with the exposure; ‘Biased’, at least one variable from the true model was not selected; ‘Correct’, selected set of variables matches the true model; ‘Inflated’, selected set of variables contains all variables of the true model and at least one further variable. Full details on the simulation setup are contained in the Methods section.