Table 2.
Authors and design | Subjects | Cycle phases | Task | Result | Cohen's d |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
LONGITUDINAL | |||||
Becker et al., 1982a | 14 NC | Once daily 2 cycles | Spatial math test | ↑ early follicular | |
Hampson, 1990 | 50 NC | 3–5/–16 | Space relations | ↑early follicularc | |
Rod and Frame | |||||
Hidden Figures Test | |||||
Phillips and Sherwin, 1992 | 25 NC | 3–4/19–24 | Visual reproduction (VMS) | ↑ early follicular | |
Gordon and Lee, 1993b | 34 NC/34 OC | 2–3/10–14/20–24 | Point Location | No effect of phase or OC | |
Perceptual closure | No effect of phase | ||||
Epting and Overman, 1998 | 27 NC | 3–4/21–22 | Rod and Frame | No effect of phase | 0.18 |
Object location (Silverman) | No effect of phase | 0.35 | |||
Water Level | No effect of phase | 0.09 | |||
Mordecai et al., 2008 | 16 NC/20 OC | 2–4/20–22 | Brief Visuospatial Memory Test | No effect of phase or OC | 0.13 |
Solis-Ortiz and Corsi-Cabrera, 2008 | 9 NC | 1–2/13–14/20–21/24–25 | Hidden Figures Test | No effect of phase | |
Localization Test | ↓ early follicular | ||||
Weis et al., 2011 | 14 NC | 1–3/9–11/21–23 | Figure comparison test | No effect of phase | |
Hausmann et al., 2000 | 8 NC | 2/22 | Hidden Figures Test | No effect of phase | 0.13 |
CROSS-SECTIONAL | |||||
Halari et al., 2005 | 42 NC | 3–7 | Benton line orientation | No hormonal correlations | |
Hampson et al., 2014d | 44 NC | Low E2/high E2 | Perceptual closure | ↑ low estradiol |
NC, normal cycling; OC, oral contraceptive users; E2, estradiol; VMS, Wechsler memory scale.
Unbalanced design.
Composite score consisting of Shepard Metzler, 3D clocks, point location, and a test of perceptual closure was reported.
Composite score of the three tests were used for statistical analyses, a polynomal correlation with E2 was also reported.
Subjects were grouped according to saliva estradiol concentrations, regardless if tests had been made in the follicular or luteal phase.