Table 3.

Phase 2 load, pull and peel test results for 16 potential durable wall lining fixing products

Type of fixing	Product #	Product	Peel test on clay: Maximum load before fixing failure (kg)	Peel test on concrete: Maximum load before fixing failure (kg)	Pull test on clay: Maximum load before fixing failure (kg)	Pull test on concrete: Maximum load before fixing failure (kg)	Load test on clay: Fixing attached to wall with 6 kg at 240 hrs	Load test on concrete: Fixing attached to wall with 6 kg at 240 hrs
Mechanical	56	Marked nail with Bostitch® plastic cap	8.0	12.0	19.2	18.6	Yes	Yes
Mechanical	59	Spiral shank nail with Bostitch® plastic cap	5.6	6.2	17.4	17.0	Yes	Yes
Mechanical	8	Metal staples (edged, large)	4.0	3.0	9.8	14.8	Yes	Yes
Mechanical	60	Marked nail	4.0	2.4	6.0	1.4	No	Yes
Mechanical	62	Spiral shank nail #59 with Grip Rite® plastic cap	3.4	5.0	19.0	17.2	Yes	Yes
Mechanical	3c	Roofing nail (large) with Grip Rite® plastic cap	3.0	14.6	4.0	18.2	Yes	Yes
Mechanical	3b	Roofing nail (medium) with Grip Rite® plastic cap	3.0	5.2	18.5	18.6	Yes	Yes
Mechanical	63	Roofing nail from #3b with Bostitch® plastic cap	3.0	5.2	19.0	18.6	Yes	Yes
Mechanical	61	Roofing nail #3 with Bostitch® plastic cap	2.0	3.2	19.0	16.2	Yes	Yes
Mechanical	58	Fasteners	1.8	0	7.1	0	Yes	Yes
Mechanical	57	Fluted shank masonry with Bostitch® plastic cap	1.6	3.0	3.6	6.8	Yes	No
Glue	67	3 M Spray	0.8	1.0	4.8	3.5	No	No
Mechanical	3	Roofing nail (small) with Grip Rite® plastic cap	0.2	0.4	15.8	18.6	Yes	Yes
Glue	36	PowerGrab	0	1.8	0.2	9.4	No	No
Glue	37	Liquid Nails® (LN-700)	0	1.2	3.8	4.5	No	No
Glue	68	Liquid Nails® (LN-701)	0	0.8	0.2	5.0	No	No

Products are ranked according to their performance during the peel test on clay.