Table 1.
Name | Assignment Strategy | Advantages | Disadvantages |
---|---|---|---|
Bradbury [25] | Compare experimental pKa values to model compounds and predicted electrostatic interactions from the X-ray crystal structure |
Assignment of the α-amine and ε-amines involved in electrostatic interactions |
Relies on the 3D protein structure; pKa values were not sufficient to assign all ε- amines |
Compare selective broadening effects of Gd3+ to predictions from the X-ray crystal structure |
Assignment of amines within 24 Å of the paramagnetic ion |
Relies on the 3D protein structure; relies on a known paramagnetic ion-binding site |
|
Gerken [37] | Compare experimental pKa values and chemical shift to model compounds and predicted electrostatic interactions from the X-ray crystal structure |
Assignment of the α-amine and ε-amines involved in electrostatic interactions |
Relies on the 3D protein structure; pKa values were not sufficient to assign all ε- amines |
Macnaughtan [38] | Correlates isotope- incorporation measurements from NMR peaks and MS isotopic profiles of tryptic peptides |
Does not require a 3D protein structure |
Degenerate isotope- incorporation limits absolute assignments; the α- and ε- amines must be separated to measure the MS isotopeincorporation |
Roberson [39] | Uses pH to alter the relative rates of the α-amine reaction compared to the ε-amines |
Does not require a 3D protein structure; absolute assignment of the α-amine; the MS isotope-incorporation of an ε-amine near the N- terminus can be measured |
Limited to assigning the α- amine and one ε-amine near the N-terminus |
Uses aminopeptidase to assign the α-amine and an ε- amine near the N-terminus |
Does not require a 3D protein structure |
Limited to assigning the α- amine and one ε-amine near the N-terminus; relies on aminopeptidase activity toward the protein of interest |
|
Larda [2] | Compares spin-label-induced line broadening with predictions from the X-ray crystal structure |
Assignment of amines affected differently by soluble spin-labels |
Relies on the 3D protein structure and data from another method |