Skip to main content
. 2014 Dec 5;9(12):e114306. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0114306

Table 2. Comparison with major frameworks.

CIA Principles Proposed Framework Frameworks related to features
Confidentiality Accountability, Access control, Disclosure of data, Treatment Pr9/CL4/CL1 ONC1, ONC2, HPP3, BP3, CF1, CF6, CCHIT4, CCHIT 5, CCHIT 6, CCHIT 7, BP9, CF9, ONC5, HPP2, BP4, BP6, CF4, CF7
Integrity Data quality/integrity, Informed consent Pr2/Pr5 ONC6, ONC7, BP7, BP8, CF6, CF7, ONC4, HPP4, HPP6, BP5, CF1, CF3, CCHIT1, CCHIT3
Availability Access control, Disclosure of data Pr2/Pr1/Pr7/CL2/CL4/CLP2 ONC1, ONC2, HPP3, BP3, CF1, CF6, CCHIT4, CCHIT 5, CCHIT 6, CCHIT 7, ONC5, HPP2, BP4, BP6, CF4, CF7
Authenticity Data quality/integrity, Informed consent, Transparency Pr1/Pr6/Pr4/CL3 ONC6, ONC7, BP7, BP8, CF6, CF7, ONC4, HPP4, HPP6, BP5, CF1, CF3, CCHIT1, CCHIT3, ONC1, ONC 3, ONC 4, HPP 4, HPP 6, BP1, CF2
Protection safe guard CL4/CLP5/Pr4/Pr10 This feature is not available in any of them
Non-repudiation Transparency, Informed consent, Disclosure of data Pr1/Pr8/Pr2/CLP1 ONC1, ONC 3, ONC 4, HPP4, HPP 6, BP1, CF1, CF2, CCHIT3, ONC4, HPP4, HPP 6, BP5, CF3, CCHIT1, CCHIT3, ONC5, HPP2, BP4, BP6, CF4, CF7
Information security analysis Informed consent, Access control, Accountability CL4/CLP3/CLP4 ONC4, HPP4, HPP 6, BP5, CF1, CF3, CCHIT1, CCHIT3, ONC1, ONC2, HPP3, BP3, CF1, CF6, CCHIT4, CCHIT 5, CCHIT 6, CCHIT 7
Protection safe guard Pr3/CLP5 This feature is currently not available