Table 5. Soil CEC (cmol kg−1) as affected by main effects of P application and subplot effects of cropping system in 2011 and 2012.
Year | P rate (kg ha−1) | Soil CEC of intercropped and weighted means of corresponding monocropped crops (cmol kg−1) | ||||||||||
Maize + faba bean | Maize + soybean | Maize + chickpea | Maize + turnip | Average | ||||||||
Mono | Inter | Mono | Inter | Mono | Inter | Mono | Inter | Mono | Inter | Mean | ||
2011 | 0 | 21.0a | 22.9a | 19.6a | 23.5a | 19.4a | 23.7a | 20.4a | 24.8a | 20.1a | 23.8a | 21.9B |
40 | 22.9a | 22.1a | 21.8a | 20.1a | 23.2a | 25.1a | 22.5a | 22.9a | 22.6a | 22.6a | 22.6B | |
80 | 29.1a | 21.2bc | 26.6ab | 27.2ab | 26.8ab | 20.3c | 26.5ab | 23.0abc | 27.2a | 22.9a | 25.1A | |
Mean | 24.3A | 22.1A | 22.7A | 23.6A | 23.1A | 23.0A | 23.1A | 23.6A | 23.3A | 23.1A | 23.2 | |
2012 | 0 | 21.8a | 20.3bc | 22.8a | 19.5c | 21.5ab | 19.6c | 21.3ab | 19.4c | 21.9A | 19.7B | 20.8B |
40 | 22.2bc | 19.8d | 22.2bc | 19.6d | 22.2bc | 23.4ab | 24.0a | 21.6c | 22.6A | 21.1B | 21.9A | |
80 | 20.4abc | 21.2abc | 20.5abc | 20.2bc | 19.8c | 21.7a | 21.5ab | 20.6abc | 20.6A | 20.9A | 20.4B | |
Mean | 21.5B | 20.4CD | 21.9AB | 19.8D | 21.2BC | 21.6AB | 22.2A | 20.6C | 21.7A | 20.6B | 21.1 | |
ANOVA | ||||||||||||
Year (Y) | <0.001 | 0.003 | ||||||||||
P rate (P) | 0.028 | 0.151 | ||||||||||
Cropping system (C) | 0.734 | 0.292 | ||||||||||
Y×P | 0.004 | 0.055 | ||||||||||
Y×C | 0.697 | 0.499 | ||||||||||
P×C | 0.265 | 0.226 | ||||||||||
Y×P×C | 0.021 | 0.009 |
Values are means of three replicates. Values followed by the same lowercase letters are not significantly different among different cropping systems with the same P rate in one year at the 5% level by LSD (horizonal comparison); values followed by the same capital letters are not significantly different among different P rates (vertical comparison) or among different cropping systems (horizonal comparison) in one year at the 5% level by LSD. Values under ANOVA are the probabilities (P values) of the sources of variation.