Skip to main content
. 2014 Dec 8;9(12):e113984. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0113984

Table 7. Acid phosphatase activity as affected by main effects of P application and subplot effects of cropping system in 2011 and 2012.

Year P rate (kg ha−1) Acid phosphatase activity of intercropped and weighted means of corresponding monocropped crops (µg p-nitrophenolg−1 soil h−1)
Maize + faba bean Maize + soybean Maize + chickpea Maize + turnip Average
Mono Inter Mono Inter Mono Inter Mono Inter Mono Inter Mean
2011 0 37.8ab 41.1ab 53.0a 54.1a 28.9b 44.6ab 27.3b 50.9a 36.8a 47.8a 42.2B
40 32.9c 54.3ab 49.7b 62.7a 34.2c 52.4ab 46.4b 46.0b 40.8b 53.9a 47.3B
80 60.8ab 56.4ab 76.1a 69.7ab 52.0b 63.4ab 50.4b 51.2b 59.8a 60.2a 60.0A
Mean 43.8CDE 50.6BCD 59.6AB 62.2A 38.4E 53.5ABC 41.4DE 49.4BCD 45.8A 53.9A 49.8
2012 0 159.7a 153.0a 179.4a 153.4a 145.3a 133.7a 144.9a 132.2a 157.3a 143.1a 150.2A
40 96.6b 115.1b 120.0b 183.5a 107.6b 121.9b 98.8b 127.0b 105.8b 136.9a 121.3A
80 134.1ab 137.6ab 173.6a 186.3a 135.5ab 112.0b 134.6ab 150.9ab 144.6a 146.7a 145.6A
Mean 130.1BC 135.2BC 157.7AB 174.4A 129.5BC 122.5C 126.1BC 136.7BC 135.8A 142.2A 139.0
ANOVA
Year (Y) <0.001 <0.001
P rate (P) 0.002 0.077
Cropping system (C) 0.000 0.253
Y×P 0.006 0.096
Y×C 0.400 0.886
P×C 0.647 0.253
Y×P×C 0.729 0.371

Values are means of three replicates. Values followed by the same lowercase letters are not significantly different among different cropping systems with the same P rate in one year at the 5% level by LSD (horizonal comparison); values followed by the same capital letters are not significantly different among different P rates (vertical comparison) or among different cropping systems (horizonal comparison) in one year at the 5% level by LSD. Values under ANOVA are the probabilities (P values) of the sources of variation.