Table 1.
Extended From Previous Page
| Graft Type |
Total No. of Patients |
No. of Patients With/Without OA |
OA Grading System and Inclusion of OA |
| PT autograft | ACL-R = 49 | 28/21 | International Cartilage Repair Society |
| HS autograft | ACL-R = 114 | 29/85 | Fairbank 3 or 4 |
| HS and PT autograft | ACL-R = 54 | 18/36 | IKDC B or C |
| HS and PT autograft | ACL-R = 56 | 26/30 | Kellgren and Lawrence 2 or 3 |
| HS and PT autograft | ACL-R = 58 | 25/33 | Ahlbach 2–4 |
| HS and PT autograft | ACL-R = 44 | 30/14 | Fairbank 3 or 4 |
| HS and PT autograft | ACL-R = 53 | 31/22 | IKDC B or C |
| PT autograft | ACL-R = 31 | 9/22 | Ahlbach 2 or 3 |
| PT autograft | ACL-R = 25 ACL-D = 25 | ACL-R = 12/13 ACL-D = 7/18 | Kellgren and Lawrence 2 or 3 |
| HS and PT autograft | ACL-R = 57 | 34/23 | Kellgren and Lawrence 2 or 3 |
| PT autograft | ACL-R = 79 | 36/43 | Kellgren and Lawrence 2 or 3 |
| HS and PT autograft | ACL-R = 28 | 15/13 | Kellgren and Lawrence 2 or 3 |
| PT autograft | ACL-R = 28 | 13/15 | Kellgren and Lawrence 2 or 3 |
| PT autograft | ACL-R = 67 | 25/42 | IKDC C or D |
| PT autograft | ACL-R = 58 | 25/33 | Kellgren and Lawrence 2 or 3 |
| PT autograft | ACL-R = 60 ACL-D = 49 | ACL-R = 27/33 ACL-D = 12/37 | Kellgren and Lawrence 2 or 3 |
| PT autograft | ACL-R = 101 | 18/83 | IKDC C or D |
| HS and PT autograft | ACL-R = 52 | 38/14 | IKDC B or C |
| PT autograft | ACL-R = 62 | 24/38 | Fairbank 3 or 4 |
| N/A | ACL-D = 36 | 11/25 | Kellgren and Lawrence 2 or 3 |
| N/A | ACL-R = 41 ACL-D = 26 | ACL-R = 23/18 ACL-D = 11/15 | Kellgren and Lawrence 2 or 3 |
| HS and PT autograft | ACL-R = 164 | 114/50 | Kellgren and Lawrence 2 or 3 |
| PT autograft | ACL-R = 83 | 28/55 | IKDC B or C |
| PT autograft | ACL-R = 43 | 11/32 | IKDC B or C |
| PT autograft | ACL-R = 73 | 40/33 | Kellgren and Lawrence 2 or 3 |
| HS and PT autograft | ACL-R = 42 ACL-D = 36 | ACL-R = 17/25 ACL-D = 11/25 | Ahlback and Fairbank 2 or 3 |
| N/A | ACL-R = 17 ACL-D = 44 | ACL-R = 6/11 ACL-D = 13/31 | Kellgren and Lawrence 2 or 3 |
| PT autograft | ACL-R = 181 | 133/48 | Kellgren and Lawrence 2 or 3 |
| HS and PT autograft | ACL-R = 210 | 149/61 | Kellgren and Lawrence 2 or 3 |
| PT autograft | ACL-R = 90 | 46/44 | IKDC B or C |
| PT autograft | ACL-R = 40 ACL-D = 40 | ACL-R = 25/15 ACL-D = 22/18 | IKDC C or D |
| HS autograft | ACL-R = 117 | 8/109 | IKDC C or D |
| HS and PT autograft, allograft | ACL-R = 85 | 9/76 | Ahlbach |
| Open PT | ACL-R = 89 | 24/65 | IKDC C or D |
| Open PT | ACL-R = 36 ACL-D = 18 | ACL-R = 23/13 ACL-D = 10/8 | IKDC C or D |
| Synthetic allograft, PT autograft | ACL-R = 51 | 51/0 | Ahlbach |
| N/A | ACL-R = 61 | 9/53 | IKDC C or D |
| N/A | ACL-D = 19 | 18/1 | Ahlbach |