Skip to main content
. 2015 Jan;105(1):144–152. doi: 10.2105/AJPH.2014.302092

TABLE 4—

Regression Results for Evaluation of the Sure Start Program’s Impact in Areas of High-Intensity Interventions: Uttar Pradesh, India, 2007–2010

Variables ITT-L2 Over L1 OR (95% CI)a Count Vvariables Estimates IRR (95% CI)b DD Coefficientsc MG attendance Non-IV, Endline OR (95% CI)d IV Estimate-DD-LATEe IV Estimate -MG Effect -LATEf
Health
 Neonatal mortality rate 0.979 (0.805, 1.189) 0.001 0.813 (0.634 1.041) –0.414 –0.004
 Experiencing complications during labor and delivery 0.917 (0.832, 1.010) 0.135 –0.153*
 Experiencing complications during postpartum 0.839*** (0.772, 0.911) 0.085 –0.408**
 Experiencing complications during pregnancy 0.853*** (0.801, 0.909) –0.345 –0.807***
Accessing Care
 Antenatal care received 1.458** (1.149, 1.848) 0.061*** 3.829*** (3.307, 4.432) 0.091 0.161***
 2 tetanus injections 1.286** (1.070, 1.560) 0.033*** 2.817*** (2.412, 3.228) 0.100*** 0.093***
 Iron-folic tablet 1.478*** (1.215, 1.797) 0.075*** 3.380*** (2.980, 3.832) 0.171*** 0.212***
 Supplementary nutrition 1.126 (0.903, 1.404) 0.023 2.496*** (2.281, 2.730) 0.022 0.132***
 JSY received 1.168 (0.952, 1.434) 0.031 1.891*** (1.729, 2.067) 0.047 0.136*
 JSY received > 1400 rupees 1.169 (0.955, 1.429) 0.030 1.911*** (1.747, 2.089) 0.062 0.148*
 Home delivery 0.843 (0.956, 1.429) –0.026 0.560*** (0.510, 0.615) –0.036 –0.142*
 Skill attendance 1.324* (1.044, 1.677) 0.023 1.560*** (1.299, 1.873) 0.114** 0.143***
 Visit to health clinic month 1.017 (0.830, 1.244) 0.016 1.308*** (1.135, 1.507) 0.006 0.0206
 Institutional delivery 1.184 (0.957, 1.463) 0.027 1.763*** (1.606, 1.985) 0.037 0.143*
 Institutional delivery (nonemergency only) 1.253* (1.012, 1.550) 0.032 1.867*** (1.704, 2.044) 0.056 0.191**
Behavior
 Washed hands 1.147 (0.915, 1.437) 0.024 1.552*** (1.304, 1.847) 0.126* 0.103*
 New blade 1.186 (0.824, 1.708) 0.007 1.508 (0.921, 2.467) 0.029 0.029
 Nothing on cord 1.509*** (1.279, 1.778) 0.081** 2.197*** (1.901, 2.538) 0.307*** 0.415***
 All 3 above 1.507*** (1.248, 1.818) 0.078** 2.299*** (1.993, 2.650) 0.285*** 0.390***
 Delayed bath 1.956*** (1.683, 2.270) 0.120*** 2.814*** (2.523, 3.136) 0.234*** 0.387***
 First colostrum 1.803*** (1.435, 2.265) 0.114*** 3.428*** (3.040, 3.855) 0.314*** 0.323***
 Breast milk within an hr 1.896*** (1.602, 2.242) 0.125*** 2.945*** (2.686, 3.229) 0.363*** 0.471***
 Breast milk first wk 2.326*** (1.967, 2.751) 0.194*** 3.371*** (3.06, 3.707) 0.460*** 0.560***
 Exclusive breast milk 6 mo 2.024*** (1.714, 2.389) 0.086*** 3.063*** (2.743, 3.420) 0.281*** 0.333***

Note. CI = confidence interval; DD = difference in difference; ITT = intent to treat; JSY = Janani Suraksha Yojana, a conditional cash transfer scheme; L1 = level 1; L2 = level 2; LATE = local average treatment effect; MG = mother’s group; OR = odds ratio.

a

ITT results expressed as an odds ratio through use of logistic regression and random effect model, Inline graphic; where y stands for outcome variable for person i in region j at time 1; and D is treatment areas valued at 1 for L2, 0 for L1. The subscript 1 indicates follow up data.

b

Incidence rate ratio estimations for count variable through use of negative binomial using the above equation; not presented for non-IV estimations mother’s group attendance at the individual level.

c

Linear probability estimations for DD estimations: Inline graphic; T stands for time, either 0 or 1 with subscript t standing for time either 0 or 1.

d

Mother’s groups estimations without correction for selection, presented for heuristic reasons only: Inline graphic. Only odd ratios are presented; count data analyses were not carried out for pregnancy morbidity.

e

IV Linear estimation results with robust error adjustment by instrumenting percentage of women attending MG in a panchayat; these indicate village level estimations. The unit of analysis is the village/panchayat level. Denote the instrumented variable as MGIVavg; this column estimates: Inline graphic. Avg denotes averages over the village. We suspect serial correlation in this model.

f

Estimations of the following: Inline graphic.

*P < .05; **P < .01; ***P < .001.