Table 6.
Best Evidence Synthesis
Modalities Used | Clinically Effective | Clinically Not Effective | Level of Best Evidence | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Quality of Study | High | Low | High | Low | |
SMT and Exercise | Childs, 200443 Mohseni-Bandpei, 200644 | UK BEAM, 200446 | Bronfort, 200845 | Clinically effective level 2 | |
SMT and Physiotherapy | Beyerman, 200647 | Hurley, 200448 Hurwitz, 200249 | Clinically not effective level 2 | ||
SMT and Conventional Medical Care | Ongley, 198752 | Jüni, 200950 | Clinically not effective level 4 | ||
Hancock, 200751 | |||||
SMT, Exercise and Conventional Medical Care | Niemistö, 200353 | Clinically effective level 2 | |||
SMT and Topical Ointment | Zhang, 200854 | Clinically not effective level 3 | |||
Acupuncture and Exercise | Yeung, 200355 | Leibing, 200256 | Weiner, 200863 | Clinically effective level 3 | |
Acupuncture and Physiotherapy | Itoh, 200957 | Clinically not effective level 3 | |||
Acupuncture and Conventional Medical Care | Gunn, 198060 Meng, 200358 Molsberger, 200259 | Clinically effective level 1 | |||
Exercise and Physiotherapy | Mayer, 200561 | Clinically effective level 2 | |||
Conventional Medical Care with Choice of Acupuncture, Chiropractic, or Massage | Eisenberg, 200762 | Clinically not effective level 3 |
Quality as measured on Cochrane Back Review Group scale: High, ≥6; Low, < 6.
Abbreviation: SMT, spinal manipulative therapy.