Skip to main content
. 2014 Nov 13;48(24):14632–14641. doi: 10.1021/es504102z

Table 2. Personal Exposure to Selected PAHs (in ng/m3) by Fuel Type and Stove Designa.

    BaP
FLT
CHR
NAP
  N(k) AM GM GSD AM GM GSD AM GM GSD N(k) AM GM GSD
smoky coal 131(82) 74.4 44.7 2.8 65.3 19.3 4.7 94.3 44 3.6 96(60) 4200 2900 2.4
ventilated stove 72 50.2 38.1 2.1 28.7 15.6 3.3 54.3 34.5 2.8 53 2900 2500 1.9
unventilated stove 6 224.5 160.3 2.4 273.6 108.2 5.1 374.8 217.3 3.2 4 11 000 6300 3
portable stove 13 41.5 31.5 2.2 17.2 9.2 3.2 68.7 45 2.7 12 4900 3900 2.1
firepit 11 186.4 151.5c 2 228.7 147.6c 2.7 245.2 186.4c 2.1 4 17 000 14 000 2.1
mixed ventilation 25 85.7 48.1 3.2 84.1 21.9 5.4 103 45.5 4.1 19 3900 2600 3.2
unknown 4 13.2 7.7 3 1.6 1.4 1.8 7.9 4.4 3.2 4 1300 1100 2
 
smokeless coal 27(16) 15.1 10.6b 2.5 5.6 2.8b 3.2 29.3 12.6b 3.5 17(11) 3100 2800 1.6
ventilated stove 2 5.6 5.5 1.3 3.9 2.7 3.7 7 4.8 3.8 0      
unventilated stove 14 13.8 9.4b 2.7 2.4 1.7b 2.2 12.6 8.3b 2.6 9 2800 2600 1.6
portable stove 10 19.3 14.2 2.4 10.7 5.4 3.9 58.7 27.3 4 7 3600 3400 1.5
firepit 0                   0      
mixed ventilation 1 10.6 10.6   4.2 4.2   13.7 13.7   1 2000 2000  
unknown 0                   0      
 
“other” coal 24(16) 61.5 39.7 2.8 44 15.6 5.5 89.1 43.2 3.9 14(10) 8300 5400 2.8
ventilated stove 10 38.8 26.9 2.6 23.7 8.4 4.8 39.1 21.9 3.4 6 3200 2500 2.3
unventilated stove 0                   0      
portable stove 9 95.6 68 2.8 65.1 31.1 5.2 159.4 91.1 3.8 7 13 000 11 000 2.1
firepit 1 21.8 21.8   3.3 3.3   7.6 7.6   0      
mixed ventilation 4 51.7 36.4 3.2 57.4 23.7 7.6 76.2 67.4 1.8 1 5900 5900  
unknown 0                   0      
 
wood 14(8) 66.6 58.2 1.7 73.7 34.7 4 66.2 54.3 2 7(4) 14 000 5900 6.4
ventilated stove 5 73.4 61.2 1.9 73.5 19.1 6.2 73.3 51.6 2.9 2 13 000 13 000 1.3
unventilated stove 0                   0      
portable stove 4 78.4 70.1 1.7 41.2 33.5 2.4 72.2 60 2 3 21 000 14 000 3.1
firepit 5 50.2 47.7 1.4 99.8 64.8 3.2 54.4 52.7 1.3 2 2000 730 10.9
mixed ventilation 0                   0      
unknown 0                   0      
 
plant 4(4) 95.6 83.8 1.9 144.8 118.5 2.2 128.7 121.5 1.5 3(3) 26 000 20 000b 2.4
ventilated stove 0                   0      
unventilated stove 1 116.1 116.1   170 170   171.2 171.2   1 54 000 54 000  
portable stove 1 39.5 39.5   104.7 104.7   91.9 91.9   0      
firepit 1 67.3 67.3   42.2 42.2   81 81   1 10 000 10 000  
mixed ventilation 1 159.5 159.5   262.1 262.1   170.9 170.9   1 15 000 15 000  
unknown 0                   0      
 
“other” fuel 66(35) 73.8 36.9 3.3 82.6 17.4 6.6 96.3 37.3 4.3 56(28) 7600 4300 3.1
ventilated stove 12 37.5 26.5 2.6 32.4 8.6 5.5 33.6 17.8 3.5 9 4500 3100 2.4
unventilated stove 13 158.8 73 4.7 197.2 42.9 10.7 242.5 102.3 5.5 11 20 000 13 000 3.4
portable stove 6 62 40.9 2.9 37.8 17.6 4.9 81.6 49.1 3.2 5 4400 4000 1.6
firepit 0                   0      
mixed ventilation 32 60 33.5 3 70 17.4 5.6 70.8 35.5 3.5 28 4500 3300 2.7
unknown 3 21.3 16.5 2.5 12 5.4 5.4 15.7 8.7 4.2 3 4400 2500 3.7
a

Mixed ventilation, use of multiple stoves with differing ventilation designs. N, number of samples. k, number of individual subjects. BaP, benzo[a]pyrene; FLT, fluoranthene; CHR, chrysene; NAP, naphthalene.

b

Significant difference with smoky coal for same PAH and strata (Tukey HSD test).

c

Significant difference with ventilated stove for same PAH within fuel strata (Tukey HSD test).