Skip to main content
. 2014 Dec 23;9(12):e115043. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0115043

Table 6. Table 6. Table assessing the quality of study included into the systematic review.

Stated what kind of milk Measured BMI at time of sample collection Standardised time post-partum of sample collection Standardised time of sample collection Adjusted for confounders Appropriate Statistical analysis Appropriate sample preparation Small medium or large study Score Positive/negative/no correlation
Leptin
Houseknecht, 1997 X X X Small 4.5 Positive
Ucar, 2000 X X X Small 4.5 No correlation
Uysal, 2002 X X Medium 6 Positive
Bielicki, 2004 X Small 6.5 Positive then none
Dundar, 2005 Not stated X X Small 4.5 No correlation
Bronsky, 2006 X X Medium 6 Positive
Miralles, 2006 X Small 6.5 Positive
Weyermann, 2007 X X Not stated Large 5 Positive
Bronsky, 2011 X X Medium 6 No correlation
Eilers, 2011 X X X Medium 5 Positive
Schuster 2011 X X X Small 4.5 Positive
Fields, 2012 X X Small 5.5 Positive
Savino, 2012 X Not stated X X Small 3.5 No correlation
Schueler, 2013 X X Small 5.5 Positive
Brunner, 2014 X X Large 6.5 Positive
Adiponectin
Martin, 2006 X X X Small 4.5 Positive
Weyermann, 2007 X X Not stated Large 5 No correlation
Woo, 2009 Small 7.5 Positive, none after adjustment
Dundar, 2010 X X X X Small 3.5 No correlation
Bronsky, 2011 X X Medium 6 No correlation
Luoto, 2011 X Not stated X Large 5 No correlation
Luoto, 2011 X X Not stated X Small 3.5 No correlation
Ley, 2012 X Not stated X Large 5 No correlation
Brunner, 2014 X X Large 6.5 No correlation
Insulin
Shehadeh, 2003 X Not stated Not stated X Medium 4 No correlation
Ahuja, 2011 X X X Small 4.5 Positive
Fields, 2012 X X Small 5.5 No correlation
Ley, 2012 X Not stated X Large 5 No correlation then Positive
Ghrelin
Aydin, 2006 Not stated X Small 5.5 Not significant
Aydin, 2007 X X Not stated Small 4.5 No correlation
Aydin, 2010 X Not stated Not stated Not stated X Not stated Small 1.5 Not significant