Skip to main content
. 2014 Dec 23;9(12):e115673. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0115673

Table 1. Effect of grass species intercrops on bean leaf chlorophyll intensity (SPAD units), bean tissue and soil nutrients (mg kg−1) and dry bean grain yield (tons ha−1) in 2009 and 2010 near Lingle, WY.

Year SPAD Bean tissue Fe Bean tissue Zn Bean tissue Mn Soil Zn Soil NO3-N Dry bean
2-4TL 2-4TL 8-16TL 2-4TL 8-16TL 2-4TL 8-16TL 2-4TL 2-4TL yield
2009 Bare soil 1.78ab 23.85ab
Bean monoculture 29.68b 814a 910a 29a 40a 115a 140a 1.81ab 29.20a 2.3a
Bean + oat 37.20a 760ab 382c 22b 42a 97b 98c 1.67ab 17.85bc 1.5bc
Bean + wheat 37.84a 739ab 353c 22b 40a 88b 81c 2.10a 15.94c 1.3c
Bean + corn 36.89a 627b 620b 23b 42a 87b 105b 1.80ab 18.97bc 1.6bc
Bean + ryegrass 36.30a 740ab 577 b 24b 39a 97b 97c 1.41b 23.64abc 1.7ab
2TL to Flowering 2TL to Flowering
2010 Bare soil 2.21 21.76ab
Bean monoculture 25.40b 632 234 76 103 65 63 2.27 26.30a 2.8
Bean + oat 33.68a 490 315 69 58 60 49 2.06 14.48c 2.8
Bean + wheat 32.34a 591 241 84 57 70 46 1.99 13.81c 2.9
Bean + corn 32.73a 645 239 57 61 61 45 2.09 17.29bc 2.5
Bean + ryegrass 32.89a 600 280 74 59 69 48 2.16 19.58bc 3.0

Means within a column and year followed by the same letter are not statistically different (alpha  = 0.05).

Means without letters were not significantly different from other treatments within a year.