Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2016 Jan 31.
Published in final edited form as: Med Decis Making. 2014 May 5;35(2):170–182. doi: 10.1177/0272989X14528382

Appendix Table 2.

Calibration targets for the aortic stenosis natural history model estimated using (12)

Description TAVR Mean (95% CI of target) PARTNER OMM Mean (95% CI of target)
Death by any cause
 1 month 5% (2-8%) 2.8% (0-5%)
 6 months 23% (17-31%) 30% (22-38%)
 12 months 31% (23-39%) 52% (41-63%)
 18 months 37% (26-49%) 60% (45-75%)
 24 months 43% (24-62%) 66% (39-93%)
Death or hospitalization
 1 month 11% (6-15%) 12% (7-17%)
 6 months 36% (27-44%) 50% (40-61%)
 12 months 43% (33-52%) 72% (60-85%)
 18 months 48% (35-61%) 81% (65-97%)
 24 months 56% (35-77%) 90% (60-100%)
Stroke
 1 month 5.0% (3.3-6.7%) 1.8% (0.8-2.7%)
 12 months 7.8% (5.8-9.8%) 3.9% (2.5-5.4%)
Proportion of patients with NYHA class I/II symptoms
 1 month 63% (56-70%) 26% (19-32%)
 6 months 60% (52-68%) 19% (12-26%)
 12 months 49% (41-58%) 19% (10-27%)
Rate of change in symptom status (% change per month)
 1 to 6 months -0.6% -1.4%
 6 to 12 months -1.8% 0%
 1 to 12 months* -0.6%

NYHA -- New York Heart Association

*

The rate of change from 1 to 12 months was used instead of the rate of change from 6 to 12 months for the GOF scoring scheme 2 (percent error) to avoid dividing by zero.