Skip to main content
. 2015 Jan 7;8:1007. doi: 10.3389/fnhum.2014.01007

Table 1.

Theoretical perspectives relevant to integrative account of social cognition.

Theory Key assumptions Level(s) of framework Underpinning mechanisms Authoritative references
Theory of mind • Extra-perceptual mechanisms are required for understanding another’s mental states • Baron-Cohen (1995)
• Gopnik and Wellman (1992)
• Third-person mindreading— observational rather than interactive form of understanding others • Sub-personal
• Personal
• Inferential simulation
• Theoretical inference
• Blakemore and Decety (2001)
• Goldman (2006)
• Frith and Frith (2007, 2008, 2012)
• Individualistic cognitive processing • Saxe et al. (2004)
Interactionism • Mental states are directly perceivable through a person’s embodiment • De Jaegher (2009)
• De Jaegher et al. (2010)
• Social cognition at the supra-individual as evolving between interactions • Sub-personal • Embodied intentionality
• Personal
• Supra-individual
• Social affordances • Gallagher (2008)
• Gangopadhyay and Schilbach (2012)
• Cognition and perception are for actively relating to the environment
Dual process theories • Two distinct types of cognitive processes • Type 1 cognitive processes— automatic and stimulus driven • Evans (2008)
• Type 1 processes are evolutionarily older • Sub-personal
• Personal
• Type 2 cognitive processes—controlled and flexible • Frith and Frith (2007)
• Lieberman (2007)
• Type 2 processes are evolutionarily recent
Ecological psychology • Body and environment play a constitutive role in understanding the social world • Direct perception via dorsal visual system • Chemero (2003)
• Gibson (1979)
• Perception is not inferential • Sub-personal • Kinematic Specific Dynamics • McArthur and Baron (1983)
• Norman (2002)
• Perception and cognition serve an adaptive function providing an organism with means for direct interaction with the environment • Personal
• Supra-individual
• Perception-action loops • Runeson and Frykholm (1983)
• Valenti and Good (1991)
Enactive cognition • Perceptions are actively brought forth through engagement with the environment
• Perception is an active sense-making process that prepares an organism for action • Sub-personal
• Personal
• Supra-individual
• Participatory sense-making
• Social interaction
• De Jaegher and Di Paolo (2013)
• Froese and Ziemke (2009)
• Noë (2004)
• Perception of invariant information relies on specific motor actions
Brunswik’s lens model • Proximal stimuli are perceivable features of the environment • Sub-personal • Probabilistic functionalism • Brunswik (1956)
• Cooksey (1996)
• Distal features are objective states of the environment, not necessarily perceivable • Personal
• Supra-individual
• Causal ambiguity • Doherty and Kurz (1996)
• Vicente (2003)
Dynamical systems • Interactions follow dynamic laws that structure and constrain joint perception-action systems in self-organizing patterns • Sub-personal
• Personal
• Supra-individual
• Coupling of perception- action systems • Coupling of organism to environment • Marsh et al. (2009a)
• Marsh et al. (2006, 2009b)
• Vallacher and Nowak (1997)
• Dynamic laws are emergent across all size ranges of social units over varying temporal scales • Richardson et al. (2014)