Table 1.
LILLE (504 census blocks) |
LYON (511 census blocks) |
MARSEILLE (628 census blocks) |
PARIS (2749 census blocks) |
|||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
2002–2005 | 2006–2009 | p† | 2002–2005 | 2006–2009 | p | 2002–2005 | 2006–2009 | p | 2002–2005 | 2006–2009 | p | |
NO2 concentrations (µg/m3) | 33.7±6.04 | 30.5±4.6 | *** | 43.6±5.4 | 38.6±6.3 | *** | 33.0±10.2 | 31.9±9.8 | 0.27 | 47.4±9.3 | 44.2±9.9 | *** |
% unemployment | 16,2±9,6 | 14,7± 9,1 | *** | 12,7±6,6 | 11,6±6,4 | *** | 21.6±11.7 | 16.2±9.8 | *** | 12.7±5.8 | 11.9±5.5 | *** |
% single parent | 15,3± 7.1 | 10,8± 5,5 | *** | 14,2±6 | 9,2±4,5 | *** | 18.7±8.4 | 12.1±5.8 | *** | 16.2±6 | 9.9±5 | *** |
% insecure job | 12.1±4,2 | 27.2±7,6 | *** | 11,6±3,6 | 27,4±7,9 | *** | 10.6±3.2 | 25.2±6.9 | *** | 10.7±3.2 | 22.7±5.5 | *** |
% white collar | 13.2±11.1 | 11,4± 8,4 | ** | 15.4 ±10.7 | 14±9 | ** | 12.6±10.6 | 10.6±7.4 | *** | 22.7±14.8 | 21.8±13.3 | *** |
% highereducation | 8.1±3.5 | 9.9± 3.7 | ** | 9.3±3.6 | 11± 3.9 | ** | 7.8± 3.5 | 9.5±4.3 | ** | 9.4± 2.9 | 10± 3.4 | * |
% non-owner | 48,7±25,9 | 47,9±26,4 | * | 56,4±21,8 | 53,7±22,8 | *** | 53.3±22.2 | 52.7±23.8 | 0.90 | 64±20.5 | 61±22 | *** |
% subsidized house | 21,5±26,8 | 23.4±24.5 | *** | 24,4±29,8 | 21,2± 25 | *** | 19.3±28.1 | 17.5±25.3 | * | 29.2±32.5 | 24.8±28.3 | *** |
% immigrants | 4,8±4.5 | 8.2 ±6,3 | *** | 7,7±6,6 | 13,3± 8,9 | *** | 5.4±5.7 | 11.0±8.7 | *** | 12.3±6.8 | 20.3±9.1 | *** |
Medianincome (euro) | 21952±7130 | 16339±5411 | *** | 23751±6558 | 18691±5194 | *** | 21534±7383 | 16302±5672 | *** | 27636±7823 | 21638±8343 | *** |
p values for Student Paired test between periodsfor each MA.
p<0.05,
p<0.01,
p<0.001