Table 3.
Cross-Sectional Studies on Self-Reported Sleep Disturbances and Cognitive Function.
Reference | Sample | Age | Cognitive Measure |
Short Sleep |
Long Sleep |
SOL | Early Waking |
Night Waking |
Daily Naps |
EDS | PSQI/ SMHS |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Roth 1999 | 1,000 | ≥18 | Self-report | − | |||||||
Sternberg 2013d | 127,048 | ≥18 | Battery | − | − | ||||||
Stenfors 2013d,c | 8,362 | ≥20 | Self-report | − | |||||||
Spiegelhalder 2008 | 60 | ≥24 | Stroop | ns | |||||||
Jennum 1994d,c | 1,504 | ≥30 | Self-report | − | − | − | − | ||||
Kronholm 2009d,c | 5,171 | ≥30 | Battery | − | − | ||||||
Regestein 2004c | 75 | ≥45 | Battery | − | |||||||
Xu 2011d,c | 28,670 | ≥50 | MMSE, VerM | − | − | ||||||
Gildner 2014d | 32,142 | ≥50 | Battery | − | − | ||||||
Parsey 2012d | 48 | ≥50 | EPT | ns | − | ns | |||||
Ramos 2013d,c | 927 | ≥50 | MMSE | ns | − | ||||||
Miller 2014d,c | 8,789 | ≥50 | Battery | − | − | + | |||||
Lovato 2013 | 49 | ≥51 | Double Span | ns | |||||||
Foley 2004d,c | 1,506 | ≥55 | Self-report | ns | − | ns | − | ns | |||
Dealberto 1996d,c | 1,389 | ≥60 | Battery | ns | |||||||
Faubel 2009d,c | 3,212 | ≥60 | MMSE | ns | − | ||||||
Ohayon 2002,2005d,c | 1,026 | ≥60 | Self-report | − | ns | ns | − | − | |||
Amer 2013 | 100 | ≥60 | MMSE | − | |||||||
Miyata 2013d | 78 | ≥60 | N-Back, CPT | ns | |||||||
Wan 2013d | 88 | ≥60 | Battery | − | − | ns | |||||
Cross 2013 | 43 | ≥60 | MMSE | ns | |||||||
Hoch 1994 | 50 | ≥61 | MMSE | ns | |||||||
Maggi 1998d,c | 2,398 | ≥65 | MMSE | + | ns | ||||||
Adam 2014d,c | 2,287 | ≥65 | MMSE | ns | ns | ns | |||||
Habte-Gabr 1991d | 3097 | ≥65 | VerM | +1 | ns | ||||||
Whitney 1998d,c | 4,578 | ≥65 | MMSE | ns | |||||||
Foley 1995 | 9,282 | ≥65 | SPMSQ | + | |||||||
Auyeung 2013d,c | 2,947 | ≥65 | MMSE | ns | − | − | ns | ||||
Blackwell 2011ad,c | 3,132 | ≥65 | MMSE,TMT,DV | − | − | ns | ns | ||||
Cricco 2001d,c | 6,444 | ≥65 | SPMSQ | ns | |||||||
Saint Martin 2012d,c | 272 | ≥65 | Battery | ns | ns | ns | ns | ||||
Mary 2013 | 16 | ≥65 | VerM | ns | − | ||||||
Nebes 2009c | 157 | ≥65 | Battery | ns | − | − | |||||
Gamaldo 2008d,c | 174 | ≥65 | Battery | − | |||||||
Newman 1997d,c | 5,201 | ≥65 | MMSE | ns | ns | ns | ns | ||||
Gooneratne 2003d,c | 76 | ≥65 | FOSQ-V | − | |||||||
***Ward 2013d | 84 | ≥66 | Battery | ns | |||||||
Tworoger 2006d,c | 1,844 | ≥70 | Battery | − | ns | − | |||||
Hayward 1992 | 124 | ≥70 | Battery | ns | − | ||||||
Foley 1999d | 2,905 | ≥71 | CASI | − | |||||||
Schmutte 2007d,c | 375 | ≥75 | Battery | ns | − | − | ns | ||||
Chang-Quan 2012dc | 660 | ≥90 | MMSE | ns | − | − |
Studies are sorted by age (lower limit). Significant effects after adjustment for demographic (d) and comorbidity (c) variables are indicated when more sleep complaints correlate with poorer (−) or better (+) cognitive scores. Merged cells indicate combined measures, blank cells indicate not collected/reported measures, and ns indicates p > .05.
Might also or instead indicate that long sleep is associated with poorer memory
Sleep Abbreviations. EDS: excessive daytime sleepiness; PSQI: Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index (total score); SMHS: St. Mary’s Hospital Sleep Questionnaire; SOL: sleep onset latency (difficulty falling asleep)
Cognitive Test Abbreviations. CASI: Cognitive Abilities Screening Instrument; CPT: continuous performance test; DWRT: delayed word recall test; DV: Digit Vigilance; EPT: Everyday Problems Test; FOSQ-V: functional outcomes of sleep questionnaire – vigilance subscale; MMSE: mini mental state examination; SPMSQ: short portable mental status questionnaire; TMT: trail making test; VerM: verbal memory