Table 2.
Summary of study results linking myopia and high intelligence.
Study | Country | Number of subjects |
Age (years) | Range of myopia | Intelligence test performed | IQ | Test/school results |
Significance level∗ |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Young 1955 [14] | USA | 633 | 6–17 | Not specified | Stanford-Binet | Average | N/A |
P < 0.001 CC∗∗ = −0.19 |
| ||||||||
Nadell and Hirsch 1958 [15] | USA | 414 | 14–18 | Not specified | CTMM | Higher | N/A | P > 0.1 |
| ||||||||
Hirsch 1959 [27] | USA | 554 | 6–17 | Not specified | Stanford-Binet CTMM |
Higher | N/A | P < 0.001 |
| ||||||||
Young 1963 [28] | USA | 251 | 5–17 | Not specified | Stanford-Binet CTMM |
Average | Higher | CC = −0.11/0.10 CC = −0.17/0.21 |
| ||||||||
Grosvenor 1970 [29] | New Zealand | 707 | 11–13 | ≥−1.00 D | Otis Test | Higher | Higher |
P > 0.05 (versus emmetropes) P < 0.05 (versus hypertropes) |
| ||||||||
Karlsson 1976 [30] | USA | 2527 | 17-18 | Not specified | Lorge-Thorndike IQ Test CTMM |
Higher | Higher | P < 0.001 |
| ||||||||
C. P. Benbow and R. M. Benbow 1984 [31] | USA | 416 | 13 | Not specified | Scholastic Aptitude Test | Higher | Higher | P < 0.05 |
| ||||||||
Rosner and Belkin 1987 [32] | Israel | 157 748 | 17–19 | ≤6/7.5 VA | Verbal Otis Test, Raven Matrix Test | Higher | Higher | Strongly positive association |
| ||||||||
Williams et al., 1988 [13] | New Zealand | 537 | 7–11 | ≥−0.5 D | WISC-R IQ Test Burt Word Reading Test |
Higher | Higher | P < 0.05 |
| ||||||||
Teasdale et al., 1988 [33] | Denmark | 15 834 | 18 | ≥−0.25 D to ≤−7.5 D | Group IQ Scores Educational levels |
Higher | Higher | P < 0.001 |
| ||||||||
Dolezalova and Mottlova 1995 [12] | Czech Republic | 225 | 14–18 | Unknown† | School test scores | Higher | Higher | Unknown† |
| ||||||||
Saw et al., 2004 [34] | Singapore | 1204 | 10–12 | ≥−0.5 D | Raven Matrix Test | Higher | N/A | P < 0.05 |
| ||||||||
Saw et al., 2006 [35] | Singapore | 994 | 7–9 | ≥−0.5 D | Raven Matrix Test | Higher | Higher | P < 0.05 |
| ||||||||
Dirani et al., 2010 [36] | Singapore | 1143 | 9-10 | ≥−0.5 D | Raven Matrix Test | Average | Average |
P > 0.38 (9-year-olds) P > 0.27 (10-year-olds) |
| ||||||||
Akrami et al., 2012 [37] | Iran | 137 | 10–14 | ≥−0.5 D | Unspecified school tests | Average | N/A | P = 0.465 |
* P score < 0.05 denotes statistically significant result.
∗∗CC: correlation coefficient.
†Data unavailable in English language at time of the literature review.