Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2016 Jan 31.
Published in final edited form as: Schizophr Res. 2014 Dec 24;161(0):329–339. doi: 10.1016/j.schres.2014.12.008

Table 3. DTI studies of relatives of bipolar disorders.

Authors Sample Mean age (years) ±SD DTI method Analysis method Abnormalities in relatives compared to healthy controls Additional modalities Comments/limitations
Frazier et al., 2007 7 Relatives
8 HC
10 DSM-IV BD-I
8.9±3.0
9.2±2.4
9.2±3.0
1.5 T ROI Reduced FA in the bilateral SLF I Clinical characteristics
  • The patients and the relatives weren't biologic relatives

  • The participants were aged 4 to12 years old.

  • HC had no history of DSM-IV axis I diagnosis

  • HC had no family history of psychiatric disorders in first degree relatives

  • Exclusion criteria for all groups were: learning disabilities, history of claustrophobia, autism, schizophrenia, anorexia or bulimia nervosa, alcohol and drug dependence/abuse (during2 months prior to scan, ortotal past history of more than12 months), history of ECT

  • All of the relatives had ADHD and/or CODD and/or diagnosis of anxiety disorder

  • One child in the relatives group was taking stimulant treatment

  • Not indicated whether the proband of relatives had psychotic symptoms during affective episodes or type of bipolar disorder

Chaddock et al., 2009 21 Relatives
18 HC
19 DSM-IV BD-I
42.5±13.6
41.7±12.2
43.3±10.2
1.5 T VBA There were no significant FA differences Genetic liability
  • All of the patients had experienced psychotic symptoms during episode of illness exacerbation

  • Patients and relatives were biologically related

  • Substance or alcohol dependence in the 12 months prior to assessment was the exclus(X00131)on criteria for all groups

  • None of the relatives or HC had ever experienced a psychotic illness

  • Four of the relatives fulfilled criteria for a non-psychotic Axis I disorder during their lifetime

  • None of the relatives were taking psychotropic medication at the time of scanning

  • In HC group, one participant fulfilled lifetime DSM-IV criteria for major depressive disorder, and one participant for alcohol misuse (both recovered)

  • None of the HC had ever received psychotropic medication.

Versace et al., 2010 20 healthy offspring (BD) (HBO)
25 HC offspring (HC) (CONT)
13.2±2.5
13.9±2.6
3 T TBSS
  • In the region of CC HBO had greater FA and decreased RD

  • In the region of the right ILF in the temporal pole HBO had decreased RD

  • In the region of the right ILF in the visual cortex HBO had greater AD

Age related analysis
  • Participants didn't endorse any current DSM-IV Axis I diagnosis or a history of depression or BD

  • Parents of the HBO were diagnosed with BD-I, BD-II,BD NOS.

  • Parents of the CONT didn't have any current Axis I disorder or history of mood disorder or psychotic disorder

  • Participants in this study were aged 8 to 17

  • Not indicated whether the parents of the HBO had psychotic symptoms during affective episodes

Sprooten et al., 2011 117 Relatives
79 HC
21.0±2.8
20.8±2.3
1.5 T VBA
TBSS
VBA showed reduced FA in:
  • The genu and parts of the splenium of the CC

  • Internal and external capsules

  • ILF

  • SLF

  • IFOF

  • AF

  • UF

  • Parts of the CS tract

  • Subcortical WM mainly in the parietal and frontal lobes

TBSS showed reduced FA in:
  • CC

  • Internal and external capsules (including anterior thalamic radiations)

  • ILF

  • SLF

  • IFOF

  • UF

  • Parts of the CS tract

  • Subcortical WM around the central sulci

Cyclothymic temperament
  • Relatives had at least one first-degree or two second-degree relatives with BD-I (diagnosed with DSM-IV)

  • No participant had an Axis I disorder

  • To optimize matching on key confounds, control subjects were recruited from the social networks of the high risk subjects themselves

  • Not indicated whether the proband of relatives had psychotic symptoms during affective episodes

Mahon et al., 2013 15 Siblings
27 HC
26 DSM-IV BD (I-II)
42.0±11.7
40.8±12.5
40.6±12.4
3 T TBSS Probabilistic Tractography TBSS showed reduced FA in the right temporal WM
Probabilistic tractography indicated reduced FA along the right IFOF
Impulsivity measures
  • Some of the siblings were biologically related to patients in the study

  • Patients were diagnosed with BD-I or BD-II (diagnosed with DSM-IV)

  • Siblings and HC were free from current Axis I major mood or psychotic disorders

  • Siblings were at least 25 years of age and were past the age of onset in their affected sibling

  • One sibling met criteria for a single postpartum depressive episode that remitted without treatment, two other siblings met criteria for prior substance use disorders, and one of these siblings also met criteria for Anxiety Disorder NOS

  • One sibling was being treated with a SSRI for anxiety; all other siblings and HC were free from psychotropic medication

  • Not indicated whether the proband of relatives had psychotic symptoms during affective episodes

Linke et al., 2013 22 Relatives
22 HC
28±11
28±10
3 T ROI Reduced FA in:
  • The right ALIC

  • The right UF

Increased RD in the right ALIC
Executive functions
Correlations between FA values and executive functions
  • Relatives and HC had no Axis I or Axis II disorder

  • HC had no mental disorder in their first degree relatives

  • Eleven relatives were from simplex families (one case of BD-I in the family), there maining eleven were from multiplex families (two or more cases of BD-I in the family)

  • Not indicated whether the proband of relatives had psychotic symptoms during affective episodes

Emsell et al., 2013 21 Relatives
18 HC
19 DSM-IV BD-I
42.5±13.6
41.7±12.2
43.3±10.2
1.5 T Tractography There were no significant FA or RD differences. Genetic liability
  • This study is an extention of a previously published study(Chaddock et al, 2009)

  • All of the patients had experienced psychotic symptoms during episode of illness exacerbation

  • Patients and relatives were biologically related

  • Substance or alcohol dependence in the 12 months prior to assessment was the exclusion criteria for all groups

  • None of the relatives or HC had ever experienced a psychotic illness

  • Four of the relatives fulfilled criteria for a non-psychotic Axis I disorder during their lifetime

  • None of the relatives were taking psychotropic medication at the time of scanning

  • In HC group, one participant fulfilled lifetime DSM-IV criteria for major depressive disorder, and one participant for alcohol misuse (both recovered)

  • None of the HC had ever received psychotropic medication.

Sprooten et al., 2013 60 Siblings
46 HC
64 DSM-IV BD-I
30.4±12.5
30.1±10.6
31.7±11.4
3 T TBSS ROI TBSS indicated reduced FA in:
  • Splenium/ body of CC

  • Posterior tatamic radiations

  • Posterior corona radiata

  • Left SLF

ROI didn't indicate significant differences
Correlations with clinical measures and potential confounds
  • Patients and relatives were biologically related

  • Some of the patients had episodes with psychotic features

  • Sibling were mostly past the typical age of BD onset

  • Siblings were not excluded for anxiety disorders, a single episode of major depression, or past substance abuse or dependence

  • HC subjects had no lifetime history of axis I psychiatric disorder or family history of mood or psychotic disorders

  • Participants were excluded for alcohol or drug abuse or dependence within the past six months

HC, healthy controls; BD, bipolar disorder; BD NOS, bipolar disorder not other specified; HBO, healthy offspring with a parent diagnosed with bipolar disorder; CONT; healthy control offspring of healthy parents; ADHD, attention deficit hyperactivity disorder; CODD, conduct/oppositional defiant disorder; DTI, diffusion tensor imaging; ROI, region of interest; VBA, voxel based approach; TBSS, tract-based spatial statistics; FA, fractional anisotropy; RD, radial diffusivity; AD, axial diffusivity, WM, white matter; SLF, superior longitudinal fasciculus; CC, corpus callosum; ILF, inferior longitudinal fasciculus; IFOF, inferior fronto-occipital fasciculus; ALIC, anterior limb of internal capsule; AF, arcuate fasciculus; UF, uncinate fasiculus; CS, cortico-spinal; DSM-IV; Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders Fourth Edition; SSRI, selective serotonin reuptake inhibitor; ECT, electro-convulsive therapy.