Table 1.
Description of the characteristics of the included studies
Source | Study type | Data source (study period) | Study location | Patients, n | Disease of admission | Study outcome | Socioeconomic variables | Follow-up period | Analytic model | Quality score |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Krumholz et al 200024 | Retrospective cohort study | Medicare provider analysis and review; medical records; Hospital administrative data (1994–1995) | USA | 2,176 | Heart failure | All-cause readmission; heart failure readmission | Race/ethnicity | 6 months | Cox proportional hazards regression | 82% |
Rathore et al 200325 | Retrospective cohort study | Medical records; Medicare administrative data; American Hospital Association’s Annual Survey (1998–1999) | USA | 29,732 | Heart failure | All-cause readmission | Race/ethnicity | 1 year | Multivariate logistic regression | 80% |
Schwarz et al 200328 | Prospective cohort study | Medical records; self report (not given) | USA | 156 | Heart failure | All-cause readmission | Education | 90 days | Cox proportional hazards regression | 84% |
Rathore et al 200629 | Retrospective cohort study | Medicare administrative data; medical records (1998–1999) | USA | 25,086 | Heart failure | All-cause readmission | Socioeconomic status (residence- based socioeconomic information) | 1 year | Multilevel variables hierarchical model | 95% |
Rodríguez-Artalejo et al 200630 | Prospective cohort study | Medical records; self report (not given) | Spain | 371 | Heart failure | All-cause readmission | Social network (married, living alone, contact with family daily, stay alone >2 hours) | 6 months (on average) | Cox proportional hazards regression | 75% |
Roe-Prior et al 200727 | Retrospective cohort study | Self report (interview); randomized controlled trial cohort (1994–2004) | USA | 103 | Heart failure | All-cause readmission; heart failure readmission | Marital status; income; education | 90 days | Multivariate logistic regression | 61% |
McHugh et al 201022 | Retrospective cohort study | Medicare provider analysis and review; American Hospital Association’s Annual Survey (2008) | USA | 590,114 | Heart failure + acute myocardial infarction | All-cause readmission | Race/ethnicity | 30 days | Generalized estimating equation models | 50% |
Joynt et al 201114 | Retrospective cohort study | Medicare provider analysis and review; American Hospital Association’s Annual Survey (2006–2008) | USA | 3,163,011 | Acute myocardial infarction + CHF | All-cause readmission | Race/ethnicity | 30 days | Multivariate logistic regression | 84% |
Rodriguez et al 201121 | Retrospective cohort study | Medicare provider analysis review; American Hospital Association; Hospital Quality Alliance (2006–2008) | USA | 1,734,101 | Heart failure + acute myocardial infarction | All-cause readmission | Race/ethnicity | 30 days | Multivariate logistic regression | 84% |
Howie-Esquivel et al 201223 | Retrospective cohort study | Medical records (2009) | USA | 809 | Heart failure | All-cause readmission | Race/ethnicity; marital status | 90 days | Multivariate logistic regression | 80% |
Lindenauer et al 201326 | Retrospective cohort study | Medicare administrative data; US Census current population survey and other claims files (2006–2008) | USA | 558,200 | Acute myocardial infarction + heart failure | All-cause readmission | Income | 30 days | Multivariate logistic regression | 89% |
Abbreviation: CHF, congestive heart failure.