Skip to main content
. 2015 Feb 5;25(2):162–171. doi: 10.2188/jea.JE20140047

Table 2. Benefits and harms of breast cancer screening by different ages for initiating and terminating screening.

Strategy Screenings,
womena
Benefit Harm

Number of
deathsa
Reduced
number of
deaths
Death
reduction,
%
Maintained death
reduction,
%b
Extended average
life expectancy,
dayc
False-positive
resultsa
Number need to
screen to detect
one diagnosis
Number need to
screen to avert
one death
Japan                  
 
Biennial screening                  
 No breast cancer
 No screening 2657
 40–69 y 1 443 763 1821 836 31 80 58 105 162 218 793
 50–69 y 947 159 1952 705 27 81 45 57 470 149 485
 40–74 y 1 704 723 1695 962 36 83 62 120 820 239 1006
 50–74 y 1 208 118 1825 832 31 84 49 73 127 176 662
 40–79 y 1 867 271 1636 1021 38 82 63 130 573 251 1141
 50–79 y 1 370 666 1764 893 34 83 51 82 880 191 777
Annual screening                  
 40–69 y 2 877 439 1612 1045 39 72 209 656 407 1785
 50–69 y 1 885 811 1787 870 33 55 114 430 278 1055
 40–74 y 3 311 710 1491 1166 44 76 235 712 439 2221
 50–74 y 2 320 081 1665 992 37 59 140 486 320 1393
 40–79 y 3 717 061 1406 1251 47 78 260 033 466 2644
 50–79 y 2 725 432 1582 1075 40 61 164 807 355 1723
United States                  
 
Biennial screening                  
 No breast cancer
 No screening 9238
 40–69 y 1 401 446 6926 2312 25 74 137 123 917 119 202
 50–69 y 906 670 7202 2036 22 74 112 75 422 80 126
 40–74 y 1 627 584 6260 2978 32 78 157 139 521 118 260
 50–74 y 1 132 808 6536 2702 29 79 132 91 025 85 173
 40–79 y 1 757 771 5902 3336 36 76 164 148 504 117 298
 50–79 y 1 262 995 6180 3058 33 77 139 100 008 87 204
Annual screening                  
 40–69 y 2 784 694 6098 3140 34 183 246 301 210 457
 50–69 y 1 797 511 6496 2742 30 147 149 544 142 277
 40–74 y 3 159 597 5403 3835 42 203 272 169 208 585
 50–74 y 2 172 414 5801 3437 37 167 175 412 149 374
 40–79 y 3 482 743 4856 4382 47 214 294 466 205 717
 50–79 y 2 495 560 5253 3985 43 178 197 709 152 475

aScreenings, number of deaths, and false-positive results are all represented as the sum total (60-year follow-up from age 40). Death reduction and average life expectancy extension were compared between 100% screened and unscreened women. Mortality rate of women with undetected breast cancer is 1.5 times that of women with detected breast cancer.
bTo examine the effect of screening intervals, the ratio of biennial-to-annual benefit were calculated (with the proportion of death reduction maintained).
cThe theoretical maximal benefits of screening were 157 days (88.15 − 87.72 = 0.43 years) and 408 days (83.03 − 81.91 = 1.12 years) in Japan and the United States.