Table 2. Benefits and harms of breast cancer screening by different ages for initiating and terminating screening.
Strategy | Screenings, womena |
Benefit | Harm | ||||||
Number of deathsa |
Reduced number of deaths |
Death reduction, % |
Maintained death reduction, %b |
Extended average life expectancy, dayc |
False-positive resultsa |
Number need to screen to detect one diagnosis |
Number need to screen to avert one death |
||
Japan | |||||||||
Biennial screening | |||||||||
No breast cancer | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
No screening | — | 2657 | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
40–69 y | 1 443 763 | 1821 | 836 | 31 | 80 | 58 | 105 162 | 218 | 793 |
50–69 y | 947 159 | 1952 | 705 | 27 | 81 | 45 | 57 470 | 149 | 485 |
40–74 y | 1 704 723 | 1695 | 962 | 36 | 83 | 62 | 120 820 | 239 | 1006 |
50–74 y | 1 208 118 | 1825 | 832 | 31 | 84 | 49 | 73 127 | 176 | 662 |
40–79 y | 1 867 271 | 1636 | 1021 | 38 | 82 | 63 | 130 573 | 251 | 1141 |
50–79 y | 1 370 666 | 1764 | 893 | 34 | 83 | 51 | 82 880 | 191 | 777 |
Annual screening | |||||||||
40–69 y | 2 877 439 | 1612 | 1045 | 39 | — | 72 | 209 656 | 407 | 1785 |
50–69 y | 1 885 811 | 1787 | 870 | 33 | — | 55 | 114 430 | 278 | 1055 |
40–74 y | 3 311 710 | 1491 | 1166 | 44 | — | 76 | 235 712 | 439 | 2221 |
50–74 y | 2 320 081 | 1665 | 992 | 37 | — | 59 | 140 486 | 320 | 1393 |
40–79 y | 3 717 061 | 1406 | 1251 | 47 | — | 78 | 260 033 | 466 | 2644 |
50–79 y | 2 725 432 | 1582 | 1075 | 40 | — | 61 | 164 807 | 355 | 1723 |
United States | |||||||||
Biennial screening | |||||||||
No breast cancer | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
No screening | — | 9238 | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
40–69 y | 1 401 446 | 6926 | 2312 | 25 | 74 | 137 | 123 917 | 119 | 202 |
50–69 y | 906 670 | 7202 | 2036 | 22 | 74 | 112 | 75 422 | 80 | 126 |
40–74 y | 1 627 584 | 6260 | 2978 | 32 | 78 | 157 | 139 521 | 118 | 260 |
50–74 y | 1 132 808 | 6536 | 2702 | 29 | 79 | 132 | 91 025 | 85 | 173 |
40–79 y | 1 757 771 | 5902 | 3336 | 36 | 76 | 164 | 148 504 | 117 | 298 |
50–79 y | 1 262 995 | 6180 | 3058 | 33 | 77 | 139 | 100 008 | 87 | 204 |
Annual screening | |||||||||
40–69 y | 2 784 694 | 6098 | 3140 | 34 | — | 183 | 246 301 | 210 | 457 |
50–69 y | 1 797 511 | 6496 | 2742 | 30 | — | 147 | 149 544 | 142 | 277 |
40–74 y | 3 159 597 | 5403 | 3835 | 42 | — | 203 | 272 169 | 208 | 585 |
50–74 y | 2 172 414 | 5801 | 3437 | 37 | — | 167 | 175 412 | 149 | 374 |
40–79 y | 3 482 743 | 4856 | 4382 | 47 | — | 214 | 294 466 | 205 | 717 |
50–79 y | 2 495 560 | 5253 | 3985 | 43 | — | 178 | 197 709 | 152 | 475 |
aScreenings, number of deaths, and false-positive results are all represented as the sum total (60-year follow-up from age 40). Death reduction and average life expectancy extension were compared between 100% screened and unscreened women. Mortality rate of women with undetected breast cancer is 1.5 times that of women with detected breast cancer. bTo examine the effect of screening intervals, the ratio of biennial-to-annual benefit were calculated (with the proportion of death reduction maintained). cThe theoretical maximal benefits of screening were 157 days (88.15 − 87.72 = 0.43 years) and 408 days (83.03 − 81.91 = 1.12 years) in Japan and the United States.