Table 2.
Data/design elements | Commonalities across sites | Differences between sites |
---|---|---|
Participants | ||
Population characteristics | • High proportion low income, CHIP eligible • High rates of obesity • 2- to 12-year-old children |
• Race/ethnic composition • Geographic location |
Participants inclusion criteria | • All sites have children ≥85th percentile of BMI as part of the sample | • BMI percentile cutoff for sample inclusion varies |
Participant sampling | • Intervention and comparison participants are drawn from populations with similar sociodemographic characteristics | • Recruitment occurs in different settings (community and/or clinic recruitment). |
Interventions | ||
Intervention framework | • Multisetting, multilevel interventions: All include interventions in ECE, schools, healthcare, and the community targeting individual and family behavior change as well as PSE changes • Cross-setting linkages (e.g., CHW, coalitions) |
• Specific interventions differ by site |
Strategies | • Increase fruit and vegetable consumption, water intake, and physical activity and improve sleep • Decrease fatty foods, sugar drink intake, and screen time |
• Specific strategies to accomplish overarching strategic goals differ by site |
Consortium | • Partners composed of public health department, academic center, and partnerships across settings and sectors | • Sites have various additional partners |
CHW | • Integrate across settings • Overarching activities similar |
• Primary setting base (e.g., clinic, community) • Specific tasks (e.g., counseling, case management) |
Capacity | • All are designed to take evidence-based interventions and build on community capacity. • All allow for additional supports to be leveraged by the CORD intervention |
• Capacities differ by community • Additional supports leveraged differ by community (e.g., awards of additional grants) |
Comparisons | ||
Catchment areas | • All sites selected a comparison community with similar sociodemographic characteristics, but were not supported with CORD multisetting, multilevel interventions | • Catchment community geographical boundaries vary ○ Comparison area within the same city as intervention area ○ Comparison city within the same county as intervention city ○ Comparison city within the same state as intervention city |
Groups | • All sites include groups of full CORD intervention components (public health and primary care plus) | • Sites also include one or two comparison groups of partial intervention components (public health and primary care; public health; primary care plus) |
Outcomes | ||
Data type, cohort | • Longitudinal outcome data are gathered on parents and children in primary intervention groups | • A mix of longitudinal, cross-sectional data are collected in comparison groups |
Design | • Quasi-experimental | • Some subgroups are matched or randomized |
Timing | • Two years of intervention activities • All include clinical data collected at 0 and 12 months |
• Intensity differs at different points in the interventions • Sites have additional measurement time points from data derived in clinical and public health settings |
Measures | • Common outcome measures for individuals ○ Assessments ▪ Weight-related changes: height, weight, BMI ▪ Sociodemographics ○ Behaviors ▪ Fruit and vegetable consumption ▪ Sugary beverage consumption ▪ Water consumption ▪ Physical activity ▪ Screen time ▪ Sleep time ○ Quality of life ○ Parenting strategies ○ Satisfaction with healthcare • Common outcome tools for populations ○ PSE-level measures in all settings |
• Site-specific measures assess elements unique to each site and provide additional insights on interventions. |
CORD products | • Cross-site evaluations including impact, process, sustainability, cost, and success stories | • Site-specific evaluations, toolkits, and materials |
CORD, the Childhood Obesity Research Demonstration (CORD) project; CHIP, Children's Health Insurance Program; CHW, community health worker; ECE, early care and education; PSE, policy, systems, and environment.