Table 1.
Measure | Source | Question Wording | Coding for analysis | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| |||||||||
Primary Care Leadership support | Primary Care Survey | Please rate each of the following potential barriers to providing timely follow-up for positive FOBTs, where 1 is not a barrier and 5 is a key barrier to providing timely follow-up for positive FOBTs. | 1=”key barrier” (category 5) 0=all other responses |
||||||
Not a barrier | Key barrier | Don’t Know | |||||||
1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | |||||
Not a priority to leadership | □ | □ | □ | □ | □ | □ | |||
| |||||||||
Gastroenterology Leadership support | Gastroenterology Survey | Please rate each of the following potential barriers to providing timely follow-up for positive FOBTs, where 1 is not a barrier and 5 is a key barrier to providing timely follow-up for positive FOBTs. | 1=”key barrier” (category 5) 0=all other responses |
||||||
Not a barrier | Key barrier | Don’t Know | |||||||
1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | |||||
Not a priority to leadership | □ | □ | □ | □ | □ | □ | |||
| |||||||||
Resource alignment: Tracking |
Primary Care Survey | Has your PRIMARY CARE PROGRAM assigned anyone the responsibility of tracking what happens to patients with positive FOBT results? (Select One) □ Yes Approximately how frequently does this person/s check these outcomes? (Select One) □ As needed on an ongoing basis □ Weekly □ Monthly □ Quarterly □ Don’t know □ No □ Don’t know |
1=someone is assigned to track “weekly or more frequently” 0=all other responses |
||||||
| |||||||||
Resource alignment: Colonoscopy appointment availability |
Gastroenterology Survey | Please rate each of the following potential barriers to providing timely follow-up for positive FOBTs. | 1=”key barrier” (category 5) 0=all other responses |
||||||
Not a barrier | Key barrier | Don’t Know | |||||||
1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | |||||
Limited availability of colonoscopy appointments | □ | □ | □ | □ | □ | □ | |||
| |||||||||
Primary Care Feedback | Primary Care Survey | Do primary care providers receive feedback about the amount of time it takes them to refer patients with positive FOBT results for colonoscopy? □ Yes □ No □ Don’t know How are primary care providers given this feedback? (Check all that apply) □ Individualized information at provider level □ Aggregate information at the team or clinic level □ Aggregate information at the facility level □ Other (specify): □ Don’t know How frequently are primary care providers given this feedback? (Select One) □ Weekly □ Monthly □ Quarterly □ Annually □ Other (specify): □ Don’t know |
0=no feedback 1=aggregate feedback at any frequency 2=individual infrequent feedback (less frequently than monthly) 3=individual frequent feedback (at least monthly) |
||||||
| |||||||||
Gastroenterology Feedback | Gastroenterology survey | How is feedback on the timeliness of follow-up for patients with positive FOBT results given to GI/Endoscopy staff? (Check all that apply) □ Verbally in a staff meeting □ In writing in the form of an aggregate team, clinic or facility report □ Other (specify): □ No feedback provided to GI/Endoscopy staff on this aspect of care □ Don’t know Approximately how frequently are GI/Endoscopy staff given this feedback? (Select One) □ Weekly □ Monthly □ Quarterly □ Annually □ Don’t know |
0=written less than monthly 1=written feedback at least monthly 2=verbal feedback less than monthly 3=verbal feedback at least monthly (hypothesized as the optimal category, based on prior research)(43–44) |
||||||
| |||||||||
Primary Care Incentives | Primary Care Survey | Which of the following do providers in your primary care program receive from leadership for their performance on assuring TIMELY FOLLOW-UP OF POSITIVE FOBT RESULTS? (Check all that apply) □ Recognition for good performance □ Monetary rewards for good performance □ Counseling or reprimands for poor performance □ None of the above □ Don’t know |
0=no rewards or reprimands 1=Recognition only 2=Monetary rewards (alone or in combination with other incentives) 3=Reprimands (alone or in combination with recognition) |
||||||
| |||||||||
Gastroenterology Incentives | Gastroenterology Survey | Which of the following rewards or reprimands do staff in your GI/Endoscopy program receive for their performance on assuring timely follow-up of positive FOBT results? (Check all that apply) □ Recognition from leadership for good performance □ Monetary rewards for good performance □ Counseling or reprimands for poor performance □ Other (specify): □ None of the above □ Don’t know |
0=no rewards or reprimands 1=Recognition only 2=Monetary rewards (alone or in combination with other incentives) 3=Reprimands (alone or in combination with recognition) |
||||||
| |||||||||
Demand Efficiency: Number of contraindications on screening reminder |
Primary Care Survey | Does your facility’s colorectal cancer screening clinical reminder ask about contraindications? □ Yes □ No □ Don’t know Which of the following contraindications are asked about in the reminder? (Check all that apply) □ Life limiting comorbidities/limited life expectancy □ Health issues that increase risk of complications of colonoscopy □ Recent colonoscopy □ Patient not willing to undergo colonoscopy if screen is positive □ Other (specify) |
0=none 1=1–2 2=3 3=4 or more |
||||||
| |||||||||
Demand Efficiency: Does colonoscopy consult template include contraindications? |
Primary Care Survey | Does your Primary Care program use a consult template for referrals to Gastroenterology for follow-up of positive FOBT results? □ Yes □ No □ Don’t know Which of the following items are included in the template? (Check all that apply) □ Anticoagulant use □ Anti-platelet use □ Diabetic □ Anemia/Iron deficiency □ Life expectancy or comorbidities related to life expectancy □ Previous colonoscopy results □ Physical/cognitive impairments that would make difficult to follow prep instructions □ Lab values □ Other (specify): □ None □ Don’t know |
0=some contraindications 1=indications only 2=neither |
||||||
| |||||||||
Demand Efficiency: Guideline-concordant surveillance |
Gastroenterology Survey | How soon is a repeat colonoscopy typically scheduled at your facility for the following types of patients: □ 1–2 small adenomas (<1cm) on last colonoscopy:________years |
0=not guideline-concordant (<5 years) 1=5 years 2=7–10 years |
||||||
| |||||||||
Supply Efficiency: How Gastroenterology providers are notified of FOBT+ |
Gastroenterology Survey | How is the GI/Endoscopy clinic first notified of an FOBT positive result? (Check all that apply) □ Lab sends notification directly to GI/Endoscopy □ Primary care notifies using consult template/referral □ Other(specify):(n=5 said Gastroenterology identifies FOBT+) □ Don’t know |
0=Primary care notifies 1=Lab notifies 2=Gastroenterology notifies |
||||||
| |||||||||
Supply Efficiency: Does prep instruction require a separate appointment? |
Gastroenterology Survey | What is the most typical way that patients receive their colonoscopy preparation instructions at your facility? (Select One) □ Written instructions provided with prep kit □ Written instructions mailed separate from prep kit □ Verbal instructions provided over the phone □ Individual appointment □ Group appointment □ Other (specify): □ Don’t know |
0=individual or group appointment (including those indicated in specified “other” responses) 1=all other categories |
||||||
| |||||||||
Supply Efficiency: Pre-procedure appointment required? |
Gastroenterology Survey | Do you require a pre-procedure clinic appointment prior to the colonoscopy appointment? □ Yes □ No □ Don’t know |
0=Yes 1=No |
||||||
| |||||||||
Supply Efficiency: Overbooking is used |
Gastroenterology Survey | In the past six months, did your GI program implement any of the following processes to keep up with colonoscopy demand? (Check all that apply) □ Added additional clinic hours □ Implemented make up clinics □ Added additional staff □ Increased use of contract providers □ Increased use of fee basis providers □ Overbooked appointments □ Other (specify): □ No change implemented □ Don’t know |
1=Overbooking appointments is used 0=all other responses |
||||||
| |||||||||
Patient-Centered Process: Patient notification of FOBT+ includes phone contact |
Primary Care Survey | How are patients seen in your primary care program typically first notified of a positive FOBT result? (Select One) □ Letter from primary care clinic □ Letter from GI clinic □ Phone call from primary care or GI clerk □ Phone call from primary care or GI nurse □ Phone call from primary care or GI provider □ Email or secure messaging □ Other (specify): □ Don’t know |
0=notification does not include phone contact 1=notification includes some phone contact |
||||||
| |||||||||
Patient-Centered Process: Are colonoscopy appointment times negotiated with patients? |
Gastroenterology Survey | Which of the following options best describes the most common way that patients are scheduled for the first appointment to follow-up on a positive FOBT at your facility? (Select One) □ Patient is sent a letter instructing them to come to the clinic at a specific date/time □ Patient is first sent a letter instructing them to call the clinic, and then an appointment date/time is negotiated over the phone □ A scheduler calls the patient to arrange an appointment date/time □ Other (specify): □ Don’t know |
1=Second and third response options, and other responses that include phone contact with patient 0=All other responses |
||||||
| |||||||||
Patient-Centered Process: Do prep instruction methods include opportunities for questions? |
Gastroenterology Survey | What is the most typical way that patients receive their colonoscopy preparation instructions at your facility? (Select One) □ Written instructions provided with prep kit □ Written instructions mailed separate from prep kit □ Verbal instructions provided over the phone □ Individual appointment □ Group appointment □ Other (specify): □ Don’t know |
0=Written only 1=Verbal phone and individual appointment 2=Group appointment and “other” responses that included written and verbal combinations |
||||||
| |||||||||
Patient-Centered Process: Do appointment reminders review prep instruction? |
Gastroenterology Survey | Are preparation procedures reviewed as part of the [colonoscopy appointment] reminder? □ Yes □ No □ Don’t know |
0=No reminders or reminders do not review prep 1=Reminders review prep |