Table 5.
Study | Procedure | Functional recovery (time) |
Evidence | Limitations | Possible application |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Transfer of peripheral nerves to pelvic nerves | |||||
Trumble (1935)17 |
Hypogastric nerve → pelvic nerve on one side Obturator nerve → pelvic nerve on other side Canine model |
No (hypogastric nerve) Yes(obturator nerve) (6–12 months) |
FES of obturator nerve induced bladder contractions |
Limited motor nerve regeneration (hypogastric nerve) |
Lesion of cauda equina |
Kimmel (1966)29 |
Hypogastric nerve → pelvic nerve Obturator nerve → pelvic nerve Pelvic nerve repair Arterial sleeve method Rat model |
No (hypogastric nerve) Yes (obturator nerve) Yes (repair) (2–8 months) |
Recovery of bladder function after obturator nerve transfer and pelvic nerve transfer |
Atonic bladder (hypogastric nerve → pelvic nerve) |
Lesion of cauda equina |
Transfer of peripheral nerves to pudendal or pelvic nerves | |||||
Ruggieri et al. (2008)34, 35 |
Genitofemoral nerve → anterior ventral branch of pelvic nerve Vesicostomy Canine model |
Yes (4–6 months) |
Retrograde dye evidence of axon regrowth from cord to bladder |
Sustained abdominal contraction could result in unintentional voiding; indwelling FES electrodes need improved design |
SCI in lower L and S segments, and cauda equina; patient needs control of abdominal muscles if FES not used |
Brown et al. (2011)33 |
Motor branches of femoral nerve → pudendal nerve Cadavers or canine model |
Yes (dogs) (3–6 months) |
Reinnervation of EUS and anal sphincter |
Not yet tested in patients |
SCI in lower L and S segments; lesion of cauda equina |
Brown et al. (2012, 2013)20, 21 |
Ilioinguinal and iliohypogastric nerve → pelvic nerve Femoral nerve → pelvic nerve Cadavers |
na | na | Not yet tested in patients |
SCI in lower L and S segments; lesion of cauda equina |
Direct detrusor muscle reinnervation by somatic nerve transfer | |||||
Rao et al. (1971)32 |
Obturator or femoral nerves implanted directly into detrusor muscle Intramuscular tunnel (arterial sleeve) Canine and rat model |
No (7.5–10 months) |
na | Neuroma formation; no regeneration of motor end plate; increased frequency of UTIs |
Lesion of cauda equina |
Abbreviations: →, transfer to; EUS, external urethral sphincter; ES, electrical stimulation; L, lumbar; na, not applicable; S, sacral; SCI, spinal cord injury.