Table 1.
Some differences between Somatic Mutation Theory (SMT) and Tissue Organization Field Theory (TOFT) related to interpretation of observational results
| Type of difference | SMT | TOFT |
|---|---|---|
| Summary | 1) Genetic disease 2) Focus on cancer cell | 1) Development gone awry |
| 2) Focus on tissue interactions | ||
| Mutations | Needed for cancer to develop | 1) Not needed for cancer to develop |
| 2) Genetic instability is byproduct of cancer | ||
| 3) Additional hypothesis: in some cases, mutations lead to cancer by disrupting morphostats, mechanical forces, or bioelectric signals | ||
| Adjacent tissue | Supporting role: | Key role: |
| 1) Affects fitness of clones | Cancer rises from disruption of interactions with adjacent tissue | |
| 2) Incipient neoplasia recruits stromal cells | ||
| Location of cancer relative to exposure | Cancer only arises in tissue exposed to carcinogen | Cancer can arise in tissue not exposed to carcinogen |