Table 1.

Corpus selected for the in-depth thematic analysis.

Reviewer	Reviews (Gramophone issue, page)
Alec Robertson	Aug ’34, p. 29; Oct ’35, p. 18; Apr ’36, p. 18; Nov ’36, p. 17; Feb ’37, p. 19; Oct ’45, p. 16; Feb ’47, p. 8; Feb ’48, p. 23; Aug ’50, p. 23; Oct ’53, p. 22
Roger Fiske	Jul ’55, p. 44; Nov ’57, p. 17; Oct ’58, p. 65; Apr ’59, p. 64; Nov ’59, p. 67; Nov ’59, p. 68; Feb ’61, p. 48; Aug ’63, p. 31; Jul ’84, p. 41; Feb ’86, p. 52
Joan Olive Chissell	Mar ’69, p. 66; Jun ’69, p. 53; Feb ’70, p. 54; Dec ’70, p. 86; Jun ’71, p. 54; Mar ’72, p. 74; Mar ’75, p. 81; Oct ’80, p. 71; Feb ’83, p. 52; Jun ’92, p. 66
Andrew Porter	Jun ’54, p. 42; Feb ’59, p. 60; Oct ’54, p. 50; Oct ’54, p. 51; Feb ’55, p. 56; May ’56, p. 49; Nov ’56, p. 55; Jun ’57, p. 19; Sept ’57, p. 17; May ’58, p. 16
Stephen Plaistow	Dec ’61, p. 57; Jun ’62, p. 64; Jun ’63, p. 36; Mar ’64, p. 63; Mar ’65, p. 57; Jul ’66, p. 47; Aug ’79, p. 69; Mar ’88, p. 50; Oct ’89, p. 98; Jan ’02, p. 81
Richard Osborne	Apr ’82, p. 66; May ’83, p. 49; Dec ’83, p. 84; Aug ’86, p. 49; Mar ’93, p. 73; Sept ’95, p. 83; Nov ’95, p. 146; Feb ’96, p. 75; Nov ’00, p. 86; Nov ’04, p. 79
Malcolm MacDonald	Aug ’54, p. 39; Nov ’64, p. 52; Jan ’65, p. 59; Mar ’65, p. 57; Mar ’65, p. 58; Jan ’68, p. 84; Jan ’70, p. 56; May ’81, p. 92; Nov ’81, p. 82; Dec ’81, p. 84
David J. Fanning	Sept ’86, p. 84; Nov ’86, p. 78; Sept ’88, p. 80; Jun ’89, p. 64; Mar ’90, p. 69; Sept ’90, p. 116; Oct ’90, p. 116; Mar ’91, p. 85; Apr ’92, p. 111; Nov ’92, p. 152
Bryce Morrison	May ’93, p. 74; Feb ’02, p. 63; Dec ’02, p. 72; Mar ‘3, p. 63; Jan ’05, p. 76; May ’05, p. 104; Jun ’06, p. 71; Jun ’08, p. 81; Jul ’10, p. 77(i); Jul ’10, p. 77(ii)
Jed Distler	Oct ’05, p. 81; Oct ’09, p. 88; Dec ’05, p. 97; May ’06, p. 90; Sept ’06, p. 80; Nov ’06, p. 97; Apr ’07, p. 92; Jun ’07, p. 84; Sept ’07, p. 76; Dec ’08, p. 103

The table reports names of the 10 selected critics and details of the single reviews (issue, page).