Table 4.
Percentage Change in Emissions Using B20 Relative to ULSD for 13 Test Conditionsa
| engine | calibration | BMEP (kPa) | aftertreatment | CO | NOx | NMHC | PM2.5 | EC | formaldehyde | benzene | TTVOC |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1.7 L | 2002 | idle | none | 13 | –4 | 11 | 31c | 5 | 28 | 16b | –1 |
| General | 200 | none | –3 | 11 | –21 | –14 | 0 | 1 | –9 | –2 | |
| Motors | 600 | none | –13 | –13 | –17 | –24c | –19 | 4 | –25b | –22c | |
| 900 | none | 6 | –4 | –5 | –16c | –14 | 11 | –2c | –25c | ||
| idle | DOC | 11b | 0 | 11 | 33 | 34 | 17 | 55 | 46 | ||
| 200 | DOC | –10 | 8 | –29 | 13 | 26 | –10 | NA | NA | ||
| 600 | DOC | NA | 2 | 144 | –10c | –21 | 51 | –9 | 43b | ||
| 900 | DOC | NA | 8b | 103 | –7c | –28 | 8 | –2 | 46c | ||
| 6.4 L | 2004 | idle | EGR | 21b | 10b | NA | 87b | 50 | 29b | 9 | –24b |
| Ford | 600 | EGR | 2 | 15b | NA | –24b | –46 | –13b | –14 | –32c | |
| 900 | EGR | –14b | 21b | NA | –28b | –34 | –7b | 52 | –13c | ||
| 2007 | idle | DOC + DPF | –15b | 23b | NA | –82 | NA | –29b | NA | NA | |
| 900 | DOC + DPF | –28b | 15b | NA | 25 | NA | –23b | –30 | –76 |
Positive numbers indicate greater emissions with B20. Idle conditions compare emission rates in g/h or mg/h; load conditions compare emission rates in g/kWh or mg/kWh.
Denotes statistical significance (p < 0.05; t test).
Denotes statistical significance for combined 600 and 900 kPa BMEP conditions (p < 0.05, t test, paired).