Table 1.
Studies analyzed for meta-analysis
Study | N a | Sample | % Male | Mean age (SD) | Mean days since diagnosis (SD) | Association | SCS measure | Distress measure | ESb | Average study ES for each associationc |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Agustdottir et al., 2010 | 184 | Prostate | 100.0 | - | - | SCS-GD | 3 | HADS- Depression | .270 | .295 |
HADS-Anxiety | .320 | |||||||||
SCS-CD | 3 | IES-Intrusions | .330 | .300 | ||||||
IES- Avoidance | .270 | |||||||||
Cordova et al., 2001 | 70 | Breast | 0 | 54.7 (12.1) | 718.3 (493.1) | SCS-GD | 1 | CES-D | .720 | .645 |
Ryff PWB | .570* | |||||||||
SCS-CD | 1 | IES-Intrusions | .620 | .520 | ||||||
IES- Avoidance | .420 | |||||||||
Cordova et al., 2007 | 65 | Breast | 0 | 52.3 (9.3) | 286.1 (194.8) | SCS-CD | 1 | PCL-C | .600 | .600 |
Danhauer et al., 2013 | 63 | Leukemia | - | 48.3 (15.2) | - | SCS-GD | 3 | POMS | .340 | .340 |
SCS-CD | 3 | CRR-Intrusive Rumination | .100 | .100 | ||||||
Dunn et al., 2011 | 439 | Mixed | 41.0 | 59.3 (12.0) | 612.5 (681.8) | SCS-GD | 3 | HADS-Anxiety | .490 | .423 |
HADS-Depression | .350 | |||||||||
SF-36 MCS | .430* | |||||||||
SCS-CD | 3 | IES-Intrusions | .450 | .455 | ||||||
IES-Avoidance | .460 | |||||||||
Eton et al., 2001 | 225 | Prostate | 100.0 | 65.0 (7.5) | 173.5 (156.0) | SCS-GD | 1 | SF-36 MCS | .270* | .270 |
2 | SF-36 MCS | .270* | ||||||||
Graves et al., 2012 | 264 | Breast | 0 | 50.6 (9.9) | 986.2 (474.8) | SCS-GD | 3 | FACT- emotional well-being | .230* | .230 |
Halbert et al., 2010 | 194 | Prostate | 100.0 | 63.6 (8.0) | - | SCS-CD | 1 | IES-Intrusions | .360 | .380 |
IES-Avoidance | .400 | |||||||||
Harper et al., 2007 | 216 | Mixed | 19.0 | 49.9 (12.1) | 1132.3 (840.1) | SCS-CD | 3 | IES-Intrusions | .200 | .215 |
IES-Avoidance | .230 | |||||||||
Hoyt, 2009 | 183 | Mixed | 100.0 | 67.5 (10.7) | - | SCS-GD | 3 | CES-D | .350 | .300 |
PANAS-NA | .450 | |||||||||
SCS-CD | 3 | IES-Intrusions | .470 | .470 | ||||||
Jensen-Johansen et al., 2013 | 557 | Breast | 0 | 53.6 (9.1) | - | SCS-GD | 3 | BDI | .484 | .492 |
554 | POMS | .499 | ||||||||
534 | SCS-CD | 3 | IES-Intrusions | .438 | .426 | |||||
535 | IES-Avoidance | .413 | ||||||||
Lepore & Helgeson, 1998 | 178 | Prostate | 100.0 | 67.0 | 517.4 (236.8) | SCS-GD | 1 | MHI | .410* | .485 |
156 | 2 | MHI | .570* | |||||||
178 | SCS-CD | 1 | IES-Intrusions | .480 | .520 | |||||
156 | 2 | IES-Intrusions | .470 | |||||||
178 | 1 | IES-Avoidance | .570 | |||||||
156 | 2 | IES-Avoidance | .560 | |||||||
Lepore & Ituarte, 1999 | 96 | Breast/Colon | 0 | 54.0 | 91.3 | SCS-GD | 1 | PANAS-PA | .030* | .1363 |
75 | 2 | PANAS-PA | −.010* | |||||||
96 | 1 | PANAS-NA | .320 | |||||||
75 | 2 | PANAS-NA | .200 | |||||||
Manne et al., 1999 | 221 | Mixed | 51.0 | 55.0 | 85.0 | SCS-GD | 4 | PANAS-PA | .083* | .210 |
PANAS-NA | .338 | |||||||||
Manne & Glassman, 2000 | 191 | Mixed | 41.0 | 56.3 (11.3) | - | SCS-GD | 6 | MHI- Anxiety | .300 | .283 |
7 | MHI- Anxiety | .280 | ||||||||
6 | MHI- Depression | .280 | ||||||||
7 | MHI- Depression | .270 | ||||||||
SCS-CD | 6 | IES-Avoidance | .180 | .195 | ||||||
7 | IES-Avoidance | .210 | ||||||||
Manne et al., 2003 | 140 | Breast | 0 | 50.1 | - | SCS-GD | 5 | MHI | .343 | .343 |
SCS-CD | 5 | IES-Avoidance | .263 | .263 | ||||||
Mosher et al., 2010 | 250 | HSCT | 48.6 | 50.9 (12.5) | - | SCS-GD | 3 | BSI-GSI | .443 | .443 |
245 | SCS-CD | 3 | PCL-C | .410 | .410 | |||||
Mosher et al., 2012 | 195 | HSCT | 50.0 | 54.0 (12.0) | - | SCS-GD | 1 | BSI-GSI | .420 | .470 |
2 | BSI-GSI | .520 | ||||||||
SCS-CD | 1 | IES | .370 | .385 | ||||||
2 | IES | .400 | ||||||||
Myers et al., 2013 | 150 | Gynecological | 0 | 55.8 (9.8) | - | SCS-GD | 8 | BDI | .350 | .350 |
SCS-CD | 8 | IES | .140 | .140 | ||||||
Norton et al., 2005 | 143 | Ovarian | 0 | 55.2 (11.7) | 547.9 (840.1) | SCS-GD | 8 | MHI- Depression | .34 | .350 |
MHI- Anxiety | .36 | |||||||||
Oh, 2009 | 94 | Prostate | 100.0 | 61.3 (7.2) | 51.1 (33.2) | SCS-GD | 2 | PANAS- PA | −.18* | −.075 |
PANAS- NA | .03 | |||||||||
Pasipanodya et al., 2012 | 45 | Breast | 0 | 52.4 (9.9) | - | SCS-GD | 2 | PANAS- PA | .050* | .280 |
PANAS- NA | .510 | |||||||||
Porter et al., 2012 | 52 | Gynecological | 66.0 | 60.2 (12.4) | 679.4 (730.5) | SCS-GD | 6 | POMS | .200 | .215 |
7 | POMS | .230 | ||||||||
Porter et al., 2005 | 46 | Gynecological | 76.6 | 61.1 (12.2) | 989.8 (872.9) | SCS-GD | 6 | FACT- EWB | .160* | .200 |
7 | FACT- EWB | .240* | ||||||||
SCS-CD | 6 | IES | .090 | .080 | ||||||
7 | IES | .070 | ||||||||
Sanders, 2009 | 70 | Lung | 47.0 | 66.7 (10.5) | 556.6 (646.8) | SCS-GD | 2 | SF-36 PWB | .370* | .370 |
Sandgren & McCaul, 2003 | 237 | Breast | 0 | 54.5 (11.8) | 75.0 (31.9) | SCS-GD | 3 | FACT- EWB | .492* | .560 |
POMS | .627 | |||||||||
Schmidt & Andrykowski, 2004 | 210 | Breast | 0 | 47.4 (8.4) | 687.9 (462.6) | SCS-GD | 3 | HADS- Depression | .440 | .420 |
HADS- Anxiety | .400 | |||||||||
SCS-CD | 3 | IES-Intrusions | .320 | .370 | ||||||
IES-Avoidance | .420 | |||||||||
Wagner et al., 2009 | 58 | Breast | 0 | 52.0 (12.2) | 1173.9 (1408.3) | SCS-GD | 3 | POMS | .118 | .118 |
61 | SCS-CD | 3 | IES-Intrusions | .351 | .239 | |||||
61 | IES-Avoidance | .126 | ||||||||
Widows et al., 2000 | 102 | BMT | 21.0 | 45.0 (10.7) | - | SCS-CD | 3 | PCL-C | .440 | .440 |
Zakowski et al., 2003 | 81 | Prostate | 100.0 | 59.0 (10.1) | 463.9 (416.4) | SCS-GD | 1 | POMS | .410 | .405 |
2 | POMS | .400 | ||||||||
SCS-CD | 1 | IES-Intrusions | .440 | .320 | ||||||
2 | IES-Intrusions | .200 |
Note. Effect sizes represent a positive relationship between social constraints and distress. Association: SCS-GD = association between social constraints and general distress; SCS-CD = association between social constraints and cancer-specific distress; SCS (social constraints) measure: 1 = a version of Lepore's social constraints scale that focuses on constraints from family and friends; 2 = a version of Lepore's social constraints scale that focuses on constraints from a spouse or partner; 3 = a version of Lepore's social constraints scale that does not focus on constraints from a specific group; 4 = a version of Manne's spousal social constraints scale that focuses on both spousal criticism and avoidance; 5 = a social constraints scale with items contributed from scales coded 3 and 4; 6 = a version of Manne's spousal social constraints scale that focuses on spousal criticism; 7 = a version of Manne's spousal social constraints scale that focuses on spousal avoidance; 8 = a version of Manne's social constraints scale that focuses on constraints from family and friends; Distress: BDI = Beck Depression Inventory; BSI-GSI = Brief Symptom Inventory- Global Severity Index; CES-D = Center for Epidemiologic Studies Depression Scale; FACT-EWB = Functional Assessment of Cancer Therapy-Emotional well-being subscale; HADS = Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale; IES = Impact of Events Scale; MCS = mental component score; MHI = Mental Health Inventory; PANAS = Positive and Negative Affect Schedule; PCL-C = PTSD Checklist- Civilian Version; POMS = Profile of Mood States-Total Mood Disturbance; PWB = psychological well-being.
N represents the sample size for the effect size reported.
Pearson's r. Effect sizes that were reverse-coded are followed by an asterisk.
The average effect sizes are weighted by the sample size of each effect size contributed.