Ref (type) | Population | Outcome, Interventions | Results and statistical analysis | Effect size | Favours |
Clinical cure rates | |||||
RCT 6-armed trial |
709 women with vulvovaginal candidiasis; analysis of 580 women, not by intention to treat (women with other vaginal infections excluded) In review |
Persistent symptoms
30 days
31/95 (33%) with butoconazole 2% for 3 days (intravaginal cream) 31/96 (32%) with butoconazole 2% for 6 days (intravaginal cream) 34/95 (36%) with miconazole 2% for 3 days (intravaginal cream) 45/70 (64%) with placebo |
P <0.03 for butoconazole 2% or miconazole v placebo |
Effect size not calculated | intravaginal imidazoles |
RCT 3-armed trial |
95 women with clinically and mycologically confirmed vulvovaginal candidiasis; analysis of 90 women, not by intention to treat (see Further information on studies) In review |
Persistent symptoms
4 weeks
6/20 (30%) with clotrimazole for 3 days (intravaginal tablets) 3/7 (43%) with placebo (oral) |
Significance not reported |
||
RCT |
37 women with clinically and mycologically confirmed vulvovaginal candidiasis. Women in first trimester of pregnancy, women with diabetes or with other vaginal infections, and women using contraceptive foams or jellies were excluded |
Persistent symptoms or mycological failure
27 to 38 days
4/18 (22%) with clotrimazole for 1 day (intravaginal tablet) 19/19 (100%) with placebo |
P <0.0001 |
Effect size not calculated | intravaginal imidazoles |