Skip to main content
. 2014 Jun;3(3):164–172. doi: 10.3978/j.issn.2218-6751.2014.06.11

Table 2. Evidence for survival after sublobar resection for cT1N0M0 NSCLC of 2 cm or less in size.

Author [year] No. of patients Intentional vs. compromised Mode of sublobar resection 5-YSR (%) Local rec. rate (%)
Kodama [1997] 46 (<3 cm in size) Intentional Seg. 93.0 8.7
Okada [2001] 70 Intentional Extended seg.* 87.3 0
Koike [2003] 74 Intentional Wedge: 14; Seg.: 60 89.1 2.7
Fernando [2005] 124 Compromised Wedge: 52; Seg.: 73 55.8 mo; (MST) 17.5
Okada [2006] 260 Intentional Wedge: 30; Seg.: 230 89.6 4.9
Iwasaki [2007] 31 Mixed Seg. 69.7 3.2
Sienel [2007] 32 Compromised Seg. 68 12
Schuchert [2007] 182 (IA/IB) N/R Seg. 82 7.7
Bando [2009] 68 Mixed Seg. 86.0
Watanabe [2009] 38 Intentional Seg. 74.5 0
Wolf [2011] 154 Compromised Wedge: 130; Seg.: 24 59 16
Donahue [2012] 40 Mixed Seg. 68.8%, DFS 5

NSCLC, non-small cell lung cancer; 5-YSR, 5-year survival rate; Seg., segmentectomy; MST, median survival time; N/R, not reported; DFS, disease-free survival. *, Extended segmentectomy is defined as resection of both the affected segment and adjacent subsegments plus the exploration of mediastinal and hilar lymph nodes by intraoperative frozen sectioning.