Skip to main content
. 2015 Mar 20;10(3):e0116786. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0116786

Table 2. Risk of bias assessment of included randomized controlled trials.

Bias domain Source of bias Lipton et al. 2009 (PRISM study) [16] Saper et al. 2011 (ONSTIM study) [17] Silberstein et al. 2012 [19] Serra and Marchioretto, 2012 [18] Slotty et al. 2014 [31]
Selection bias Random sequence generation Unclear risk Low risk Low risk Unclear risk Low risk
Allocation concealment Unclear risk Low risk Low risk Unclear risk Low risk
Performance bias Blinding of participants Unclear risk Unclear risk (high risk for medication management group) Unclear risk High risk Low risk (high risk for suprathreshold stimulation)
Blinding of study personnel Unclear risk Unclear risk Unclear risk High risk Low risk
Detection bias Blinding of outcome assessment: patient reported outcomes Unclear risk Unclear risk (high risk for medication management group) Unclear risk High risk Low risk (high risk for suprathreshold stimulation)
Blinding of outcome assessment: investigator assessed outcomes Low risk Low risk Low risk High risk Low risk
Attrition bias Incomplete outcome data Unclear risk High risk Low risk Low risk Low risk
Reporting bias Selective reporting Unclear risk High risk Unclear Low risk Low risk
Other bias Any other important concerns about bias not covered in the other domains above Based on conference abstract with very limited information; manufacturer-sponsored study Manufacturer-sponsored study Manufacturer-sponsored study High risk (weakness related to crossover design—see below) High risk (patients already had good treatment response; lack of washout—see below)
Measurement of effectiveness of blinding and/or patients’ expectation of treatment effectiveness Not done Not done Not done Not done Not done
Crossover design Analysis of paired data Not applicable Not applicable Not applicable Not done Yes
Assessment of carryover effects and/or justification of washout period Not applicable Not applicable Not applicable Not done Not done