Table 2. Studies included for the analysis of child maltreatment in China .
Study | Type of study | Maltreatment | Sample size | Risk of bias | Excluded maltreatment in meta-analysis | RR estimation, maltreatment – outcome |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Cai (2008)46 | Prevalence | Emotional, physical, neglect | 270 | Low | – | – |
Chan & Yan (2013)68 | Prevalence | Physical, sexual | 18 341 | Low | – | – |
Chang & Wang (2008)56 | Prevalence | Emotional, neglect | 230 | Medium | – | – |
Chen & Dunne (2003)84 | Prevalence | Sexual | 323 | Low | – | – |
Chen & Liao (2011)48 | Prevalence | Emotional | 430 | Medium | – | – |
Chen & Liao (2005)45 | Prevalence | Emotional | 484 | Medium | – | – |
Chen & Liao (2005)71 | Prevalence | Physical | 484 | Medium | – | – |
Chen et al. (2003)85 | Prevalence | Sexual | 239 | Low | – | – |
Chen et al. (2006)65 | Prevalence and consequences | Physical | 528 | Medium | – | Physical – current smoker |
Physical – problem drinking | ||||||
Chen et al. (2006)79 | Prevalence | Sexual | 528 | Low | – | – |
Chen et al. (2010)80 | Prevalence | Sexual | 2 508 | Low | – | – |
Chen (2004)83 | Prevalence | Sexual | 565 | Medium | – | – |
Chen (2005)61 | Prevalence | Emotional, physical | 291 | Medium | – | – |
Chen et al. (2004)9 | Prevalence and consequences | Sexual | 2 300 | Low | – | Sexual – current smoker |
Sexual – problem drinking | ||||||
Chen et al. (2006)8 | Prevalence and consequences | Sexual | 351 | Low | – | Sexual – current smoker |
Sexual – problem drinking | ||||||
Chen et al. (2002)7 | Prevalence | Sexual | 985 | Medium | – | – |
Chen et al. (2004)77 | Prevalence | Sexual | 892 | Medium | – | – |
Chen et al. (2008)26 | Prevalence | Emotional, physical | 528 | Medium | Emotional | – |
Cheng et al. (2010)75 | Prevalence | Neglect | 3 155 | Low | – | – |
Cheng et al. (2011)86 | Consequences | Physical | 1 628 | Low | – | Physical – current smoker |
Physical – problem drinking | ||||||
Physical – illicit drug use | ||||||
Cong et al. (2012)87 | Consequences | Sexual | 4 567 | Low | – | Sexual – depression |
Chou et al. (2011)66 | Prevalence | Physical | 1 966 | Low | – | – |
Ding et al. (2007)37 | Prevalence | Emotional, physical | 485 | Medium | – | – |
Dong et al. (2010)55 | Prevalence | Emotional, neglect | 1 193 | Low | – | – |
Fuh et al. (2010)22 | Prevalence | Physical | 4 259 | Medium | Physical | – |
Gao et al. (2011)43 | Prevalence | Emotional, physical, neglect | 301 | Medium | – | – |
Gao et al. (2013)73 | Prevalence | Neglect | 685 | Low | – | – |
Gu et al. (2005)78 | Prevalence | Sexual | 1 635 | Medium | – | – |
Hester et al. (2009)67 | Prevalence | Physical | 498 | Medium | – | – |
Hou et al. (2010)58 | Prevalence | Emotional | 757 | Medium | – | – |
Hu et al. (2005)39 | Prevalence | Emotional, physical | 336 | Medium | – | – |
Huang et al. (2006)36 | Prevalence | Emotional, physical, neglect | 335 | Medium | – | – |
Lau et al. (2003)88 | Consequences | Physical | 489 | Low | – | Physical – current smoker |
Physical – self-harm | ||||||
Lau et al. (2005)89 | Consequences | Physical | 95 788 | Low | – | Physical – current smoker |
Physical – illicit drug use | ||||||
Li et al. (2012)90 | Consequences | Sexual | 4 084 | Low | – | Sexual – depression |
Sexual – anxiety | ||||||
Li et al.a (2014)60 | Prevalence | Emotional, physical | 485 | Low | – | – |
Lin et al. (2011)42 | Prevalence | Emotional, physical | 7 475 | Low | – | – |
Lin et al. (2011)76 | Prevalence | Sexual | 683 | Low | – | – |
Lu et al. (2012)24 | Prevalence | Emotional, physical | 796 | Medium | Emotional | – |
Ma & Chen (2007)70 | Prevalence and consequences | Physical | 709 | Medium | – | Physical– mental disorder |
Physical – depression | ||||||
Physical – anxiety | ||||||
Physical – current smoker | ||||||
Physical – problem drinking | ||||||
Ma et al. (2005)11 | Prevalence and consequences | Physical | 528 | Medium | – | Physical – mental disorder |
Physical – depression | ||||||
Physical – anxiety | ||||||
Ma et al. (2012)28 | Prevalence | Emotional, physical, neglect | 475 | Low | Neglect | – |
Qiu & Ma (2010)25 | Prevalence | Physical, sexual | 709 | Medium | Physical | – |
Samuda (1988)62 | Prevalence | Physical | 100 | Medium | – | – |
Shen (2009)69 | Prevalence | Physical | 1 924 | Low | – | – |
Su et al. (2008)81 | Prevalence and consequences | Sexual | 1 386 | Medium | – | Sexual – depression |
Sexual – anxiety | ||||||
Sexual – self-harm | ||||||
Sun et al. (2006)82 | Prevalence | Sexual | 701 | Medium | – | – |
Tang (2002)10 | Prevalence | Sexual | 2 147 | Medium | – | – |
Tang et al. (2011)91 | Consequences | Physical | 6 564 | Low | – | Physical – current smoker |
Physical – self-harm | ||||||
Tao et al. (2006)57 | Prevalence and consequences | Emotional, physical | 5 141 | Medium | – | Physical – mental disorder |
Emotional – mental disorder | ||||||
Wang & Chen (2012)40 | Prevalence | Emotional, physical | 1 762 | Medium | – | – |
Xiao et al. (2008)72 | Prevalence and consequences | Physical | 10 894 | Medium | – | Physical – self-harm |
Emotional – self-harm | ||||||
Xiao (2008)59 | Prevalence | Emotional, physical, neglect | 2 073 | Low | – | – |
Xie et al. (2008)27 | Prevalence | Emotional, neglect | 457 | Low | Neglect | – |
Yan et al. (2009)51 | Prevalence | Emotional, physical | 1 200 | Low | – | – |
Yang et al. (2004)23 | Prevalence | Emotional, physical, neglect | 282 | Medium | Emotional, physical, neglect | – |
Yang (2012)54 | Prevalence | Emotional, neglect | 324 | Low | – | – |
Ye et al. (2006)63 | Prevalence | Physical, sexual | 5 141 | Medium | – | – |
Yen et al. (2008)64 | Prevalence | Physical | 1 684 | Low | – | – |
Yong et al. (2011)52 | Prevalence | Emotional, physical | 1 417 | Low | – | – |
Zeng et al. (2010)44 | Prevalence | Emotional, physical, neglect | 667 | Low | – | – |
Zhang et al. (2010)74 | Prevalence | Neglect | 3 539 | Low | – | – |
Zhao & Li (2006)38 | Prevalence | Emotional, physical | 485 | Medium | – | – |
Zhao et al. (2004)47 | Prevalence | Emotional, physical, neglect | 435 | Low | – | – |
Zhong et al. (2012)41 | Prevalence | Emotional, physical | 456 | Medium | – | – |
Zhou et al. (2010)50 | Prevalence | Emotional, neglect | 397 | Low | – | – |
Zhu et al. (2010)49 | Prevalence | Emotional, neglect | 659 | Low | – | – |
Zhu et al. (2012)53 | Prevalence | Emotional, physical, neglect | 2 374 | Low | – | – |
RR: relative risk.
a This study was available online 22 October 2013 and therefore included in our systematic review.