Skip to main content
. 2015 Jan 20;93(3):176–185C. doi: 10.2471/BLT.14.140970

Table 2. Studies included for the analysis of child maltreatment in China .

Study Type of study Maltreatment Sample size Risk of bias Excluded maltreatment in meta-analysis RR estimation, maltreatment – outcome
Cai (2008)46 Prevalence Emotional, physical, neglect 270 Low
Chan & Yan (2013)68 Prevalence Physical, sexual 18 341 Low
Chang & Wang (2008)56 Prevalence Emotional, neglect 230 Medium
Chen & Dunne (2003)84 Prevalence Sexual 323 Low
Chen & Liao (2011)48 Prevalence Emotional 430 Medium
Chen & Liao (2005)45 Prevalence Emotional 484 Medium
Chen & Liao (2005)71 Prevalence Physical 484 Medium
Chen et al. (2003)85 Prevalence Sexual 239 Low
Chen et al. (2006)65 Prevalence and consequences Physical 528 Medium Physical – current smoker
Physical – problem drinking
Chen et al. (2006)79 Prevalence Sexual 528 Low
Chen et al. (2010)80 Prevalence Sexual 2 508 Low
Chen (2004)83 Prevalence Sexual 565 Medium
Chen (2005)61 Prevalence Emotional, physical 291 Medium
Chen et al. (2004)9 Prevalence and consequences Sexual 2 300 Low Sexual – current smoker
Sexual – problem drinking
Chen et al. (2006)8 Prevalence and consequences Sexual 351 Low Sexual – current smoker
Sexual – problem drinking
Chen et al. (2002)7 Prevalence Sexual 985 Medium
Chen et al. (2004)77 Prevalence Sexual 892 Medium
Chen et al. (2008)26 Prevalence Emotional, physical 528 Medium Emotional
Cheng et al. (2010)75 Prevalence Neglect 3 155 Low
Cheng et al. (2011)86 Consequences Physical 1 628 Low Physical – current smoker
Physical – problem drinking
Physical – illicit drug use
Cong et al. (2012)87 Consequences Sexual 4 567 Low Sexual – depression
Chou et al. (2011)66 Prevalence Physical 1 966 Low
Ding et al. (2007)37 Prevalence Emotional, physical 485 Medium
Dong et al. (2010)55 Prevalence Emotional, neglect 1 193 Low
Fuh et al. (2010)22 Prevalence Physical 4 259 Medium Physical
Gao et al. (2011)43 Prevalence Emotional, physical, neglect 301 Medium
Gao et al. (2013)73 Prevalence Neglect 685 Low
Gu et al. (2005)78 Prevalence Sexual 1 635 Medium
Hester et al. (2009)67 Prevalence Physical 498 Medium
Hou et al. (2010)58 Prevalence Emotional 757 Medium
Hu et al. (2005)39 Prevalence Emotional, physical 336 Medium
Huang et al. (2006)36 Prevalence Emotional, physical, neglect 335 Medium
Lau et al. (2003)88 Consequences Physical 489 Low Physical – current smoker
Physical – self-harm
Lau et al. (2005)89 Consequences Physical 95 788 Low Physical – current smoker
Physical – illicit drug use
Li et al. (2012)90 Consequences Sexual 4 084 Low Sexual – depression
Sexual – anxiety
Li et al.a (2014)60 Prevalence Emotional, physical 485 Low
Lin et al. (2011)42 Prevalence Emotional, physical 7 475 Low
Lin et al. (2011)76 Prevalence Sexual 683 Low
Lu et al. (2012)24 Prevalence Emotional, physical 796 Medium Emotional
Ma & Chen (2007)70 Prevalence and consequences Physical 709 Medium Physical– mental disorder
Physical – depression
Physical – anxiety
Physical – current smoker
Physical – problem drinking
Ma et al. (2005)11 Prevalence and consequences Physical 528 Medium Physical – mental disorder
Physical – depression
Physical – anxiety
Ma et al. (2012)28 Prevalence Emotional, physical, neglect 475 Low Neglect
Qiu & Ma (2010)25 Prevalence Physical, sexual 709 Medium Physical
Samuda (1988)62 Prevalence Physical 100 Medium
Shen (2009)69 Prevalence Physical 1 924 Low
Su et al. (2008)81 Prevalence and consequences Sexual 1 386 Medium Sexual – depression
Sexual – anxiety
Sexual – self-harm
Sun et al. (2006)82 Prevalence Sexual 701 Medium
Tang (2002)10 Prevalence Sexual 2 147 Medium
Tang et al. (2011)91 Consequences Physical 6 564 Low Physical – current smoker
Physical – self-harm
Tao et al. (2006)57 Prevalence and consequences Emotional, physical 5 141 Medium Physical – mental disorder
Emotional – mental disorder
Wang & Chen (2012)40 Prevalence Emotional, physical 1 762 Medium
Xiao et al. (2008)72 Prevalence and consequences Physical 10 894 Medium Physical – self-harm
Emotional – self-harm
Xiao (2008)59 Prevalence Emotional, physical, neglect 2 073 Low
Xie et al. (2008)27 Prevalence Emotional, neglect 457 Low Neglect
Yan et al. (2009)51 Prevalence Emotional, physical 1 200 Low
Yang et al. (2004)23 Prevalence Emotional, physical, neglect 282 Medium Emotional, physical, neglect
Yang (2012)54 Prevalence Emotional, neglect 324 Low
Ye et al. (2006)63 Prevalence Physical, sexual 5 141 Medium
Yen et al. (2008)64 Prevalence Physical 1 684 Low
Yong et al. (2011)52 Prevalence Emotional, physical 1 417 Low
Zeng et al. (2010)44 Prevalence Emotional, physical, neglect 667 Low
Zhang et al. (2010)74 Prevalence Neglect 3 539 Low
Zhao & Li (2006)38 Prevalence Emotional, physical 485 Medium
Zhao et al. (2004)47 Prevalence Emotional, physical, neglect 435 Low
Zhong et al. (2012)41 Prevalence Emotional, physical 456 Medium
Zhou et al. (2010)50 Prevalence Emotional, neglect 397 Low
Zhu et al. (2010)49 Prevalence Emotional, neglect 659 Low
Zhu et al. (2012)53 Prevalence Emotional, physical, neglect 2 374 Low

RR: relative risk.

a This study was available online 22 October 2013 and therefore included in our systematic review.