Table 1A.
Disorder | Study design | Outcome (compared to placebo control group) | Reference |
---|---|---|---|
Healthy volunteers | 14 days po escitalopram pretreatment; fear conditioning paradigm |
Accelerated extinction learning (skin conductance responses) | (Bui et al., 2013) |
Panic disorder with/without agoraphobia |
Fluvoxamine or placebo followed by exposure therapy; psychological panic management followed by exposure therapy or exposure therapy alone |
Self-reported measures All treatments effective, however fluvoxamine plus CBT superior to all other treatments |
(de Beurs et al., 1995) |
Panic disorder with/without agoraphobia |
12 weeks paroxetine or placebo plus CBT | Reduced number of panic attacks in paroxetine/CBT group | (Oehrberg et al., 1995) |
Panic disorder with/without agoraphobia |
10 weeks of paroxetine or placebo plus CBT in week 5 and 7 |
No significant difference in primary CGI outcome. Secondary outcome: Higher proportion of panic-free patients in paroxetine-CBT group. |
(Stein et al., 2000) |
Panic disorder with/without agoraphobia |
12 weeks fluvoxamine or placebo with or without CBT |
All groups except placebo without CBT improved. No difference within other groups. |
(Sharp et al., 1997) |
Panic disorder with/without agoraphobia |
12 weeks of sertraline or placebo treatment plus self-administered CBT or no CBT |
Reduced anticipatory anxiety in sertraline plus self-administered CBT No significant improvements in CGI. |
(Koszycki et al., 2011) |
Social anxiety disorder | 24 weeks of sertraline/placebo with or without exposure therapy (8 sessions in the first 12 weeks of treatment) |
All groups improved (also placebo without CBT) Sertraline treatment (without CBT) showed higher improvement than CBT groups (placebo or sertraline). Placebo without CBT showed lowest benefits. |
(Blomhoff et al., 2001) |
Social anxiety disorder | Follow-up study of (Blomhoff et al., 2001) Assessment of long-term effects 28 weeks after cessation of medical treatment |
Exposure therapy alone (without placebo or sertraline) showed a further improvement in CAPS 28 weeks after treatment cessation, however only reached improvement levels comparable with those of the sertraline alone group after the initial 24 weeks |
(Haug et al., 2003) |
CAPS score in the other groups (Exposure + placebo or sertraline and placebo alone) stayed constant (no improvement compared to 24 week CAPS score) |
|||
Social anxiety disorder | 14 weeks of fluoxetine or placebo plus weekly CBT or no CBT CBT consisted of group treatment combining in vivo exposure, cognitive restructuring and social skills training |
All treatments were superior to placebo (without CBT) but no differences between groups themselves |
(Davidson et al., 2004) |
PTSD | 10 exposure therapy sessions (1×/week) plus paroxetine CR Optional 12 weeks of maintenance treatment |
Greater CAPS improvement in paroxetine group vs placebo after 10 weeks Higher rate of remission (61.5% vs 23.1% in placebo group) after 10 weeks No changes after additional 12 weeks. CAVE drop-out of remitters. |
(Schneier et al., 2012) |
CR…controlled release.