Skip to main content
. 2015 Mar 23;21:861–868. doi: 10.12659/MSM.894023

Table 1.

The characteristics of included studies.

Authors Publication year Country Number of Subjects NR R NR R
NR R CC CT TT CC CT TT C T C T
Alpman et al. 2010 Turkey 39 92 6 20 12 26 37 24 32 44 89 85
Haerian et al. 2011 Asian 323 362 109 158 56 110 180 72 376 270 400 324
Szoeke et al. 2009a Australia 64 148 21 27 16 34 67 47 69 59 135 161
Szoeke et al. 2009b Scotland 133 152 20 69 44 34 72 46 109 157 140 164
Szoeke et al. 2009c China 11 34 1 8 2 13 20 1 10 12 46 22
Tan et al. 2004 Australia 401 208 75 193 133 37 115 56 343 459 189 227
Chen L et al. 2007 China 50 164 15 25 10 63 79 22 55 45 205 123
Di Q et al. 2011 China 91 79 44 37 10 32 30 17 125 57 94 64
Dong et al. 2011 China 157 193 64 75 18 82 83 28 203 111 247 139
Hung et al. 2007 China 114 213 40 55 19 39 107 67 135 93 185 241
Kwan et al. 2007 China 221 297 80 104 37 114 161 22 264 178 389 205
Ufer et al. 2009 Germany 188 103 44 85 59 20 46 37 173 203 86 120
Grover et al. 2010 India 87 125 13 44 30 14 55 56 70 104 83 167
Kumaril et al. 2011 India 125 260 12 67 46 42 120 98 91 159 204 316
Takhan et al. 2009 India 94 231 9 52 33 38 104 89 70 118 180 282
Vahab et al. 2009 India 113 54 3 61 49 3 8 43 67 159 14 94
Sayyah et al. 2011 Iran 132 200 34 55 43 32 80 88 123 141 144 256
Shahwan et al. 2007 Ireland 122 233 20 64 38 37 119 77 104 140 193 273
Seo et al. 2006 Japan 126 84 34 58 34 36 34 14 126 126 106 62
Kim et al. 2009 Korea 198 193 73 97 28 81 90 22 243 153 252 134
Emich-Widera et al. 2013 Poland 60 25 9 33 18 1 16 8 51 69 18 32
Emich-Widera et al. 2014 Poland 193 135 19 114 60 21 82 32 152 234 124 146
Sills et al. 2005 Scotland 230 170 41 112 77 32 82 56 194 266 146 194
Sanchez et al. 2010 Spain 111 178 40 49 22 52 81 45 129 93 185 171
Dericiogl et al. 2008 Turkey 89 100 26 34 29 25 49 26 86 92 99 101
Ozgon et al. 2008 Turkey 44 53 13 26 5 16 29 8 52 36 61 45
Saygi et al. 2014 Turkey 59 60 19 26 14 12 30 18 64 54 54 66
Seven et al. 2014 Turkey 69 83 17 30 22 22 38 23 64 74 82 84
Siddiqui et al. 2003 UK 200 115 55 106 39 18 63 34 216 184 99 131
Soranzo et al. 2004 UK 280 136 73 145 62 20 80 36 291 269 120 152

NR – anti-epileptic drug no response (case group); R – effective group (control group). a, b, and c represent independent studies from the same article.