Table 2.
Reference | Patient | Content of MHs | Tinnitus | Hearing loss | Comorbid disorders | Results of auxiliary investigations | Treatment | Clinical efficacy | Duration of follow-up |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Ukai et al. (14) | F, 82 years | Old familiar songs accompanied by musical instruments which later evolved into monotonous, simple melodies | − | + | − | MRI: diffuse mild cortical atrophy consistent with aging | Donepezil 5 mg/day (plus polypharmacy) | Almost complete remission | 5 years |
Strauss and Gertz (15) | M, 54 years | Songs sung by a male voice, sometimes accompanied by piano or guitar, and sometimes orchestral music | + | + | Hemiparesis due to infarctions of the bilateral medial cerebral artery territories | MRI: extensive ischemic lesions in the right medial cerebral artery territory, including insular cortex and basal ganglia, and left occipital ischemic lesions | Donepezil 5 mg/day | Complete remission | 8 weeks |
Strauss and Gertz (15) | M, 78 years | Christmas carols and folk songs, sung by a male voice | + | + | − | MRI: symmetric diffuse brain atrophy and periventricular microangiopathic changes | Donepezil 5 mg/day | Complete remission | 4 months |
Zilles et al. (16) | F, 90 years | Choirs and brass music | − | + | Reactive depression | MRI: global brain atrophy, bifrontal hygromas, and a leukodystrophia-like brain parenchyma | Donepezil 5 mg/day | Complete remission | 1 week |
Blom et al. (17) | F, 76 years | Hymns, lullabies, pop songs, and classical tunes | − | + | Myocardial infarction | MRI: white-matter lesions, especially in the right inferior frontal area and the left parietal lobe | Rivastigmine 1.5 mg/day (plus polypharmacy) | Complete remission | 4 years |
Blom et al. (17) | F, 78 years | Christmas carols and (later) unrecognizable music | − | + | − | MRI: white-matter lesions, non-specific | Rivastigmine 1.5 mg/day (plus polypharmacy) | Partial remission | 3 months |
MHs, musical hallucinations; F, female; M, male.