Skip to main content
. 2015 Apr 9;10(4):e0124535. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0124535

Table 1. Main characteristics of studies included in this meta-analysis.

Study Country or Area Age (year) Design Control Inclusion criteria Instrument Dropout Quality
Cho 2005 Hong Kong 7–12 CT Spectacle -0.25DS to -4.50DS, less than 2.00DC A-scan 19% 16 (minors)
Walline 2009 USA 8–11 CT Soft contact lens -0.75DS to -4.00DS, less than 1.00DC A-scan 30% 16 (minors)
Kakita 2011 Japan 8–16 CT Spectacle SE between -0.5D and -10.0D IOLmaster 12% 19 (minors)
Cho 2012 Hong Kong 6–10 RCT Spectacle -0.50DS to -4.00DS, less than 1.25DC IOLmaster 24% 3 (Jadad)
Santodomingo 2012 Spain 6–12 CT Spectacle -0.75DS to -4.00DS, less than 1.00DC IOLmaster 13% 18 (minors)
Charm 2013 Hong Kong 8–11 RCT Spectacle SE at least -5.75D IOLmaster 46% 3 (Jadad)
Chen 2013 Hong Kong 6–12 CT Spectacle -0.5DS to -5.0DS, 1.25DC to 3.50DC IOLmaster 28% 22 (minors)