Skip to main content
. 2015 Feb 7;466(4):363–373. doi: 10.1007/s00428-015-1719-6

Table 2.

Characteristics of included studies

First author Year Country Sample size Tumor site TNM stage Reference standard Nodal metastasis a Genes Method Tissue Cutoff
Gene amplification Hanken 2014 Germany 255 Oral cavity All pN 46 % CCND1 FISH FFPE G/C ratio >2.0
Yoshioka 2013 Japan 25 Oral cavity All pN 60 % 11q13.3 CGH FFPE G/C ratio >1.12
Sugahara 2011 Japan 54 Oral cavity All pN 41 % 11 genes in 11q13c CGH Fresh frozen G/C ratio >1.5 in ≥3 genes
Pathare 2011 India 97 Oral cavity N.A. pN 56 % 11q13 CGH Fresh frozen G/C ratio >1.25
Michikawa 2011 Japan 127 Oral cavity All pN 42 % CCND1 FISH Fixed FNA G/C ratio >1.2 and gene/cell ratio >3
Mahdey 2011 Malaysia 50 Cheek and tongue All pN 54 % CCND1 FISH FFPE G/C Ratio >2.0
Prapinjumruneb 2010 Japan 60 Tongue T1-2 pN or FU 43 % FADD RT-PCR FFPE G/C ratio >1.5
Myo 2005 Japan 45 Oral cavity cT1-2N0 pN or FU 38 % CCND1 FISH Fixed FNA >20 % of 100 cells ≥3 spots
Fujii 2001 Japan 23 Tongue All pN or FU 61 % CCND1 FISH FFPE >20 % of 100 cells ≥3 spots
Protein overexpression Huang 2012 Taiwan 264 Oral cavity All pN 48 % CCND1 IHC FFPE 10 % staining
Prapinjumrune b 2010 Japan 60 Tongue T1-2 pN or FU 40 % FADD IHC FFPE 29.2 % staining
Shah 2009 India 135 Cheek and tongue All pN 33 % CCND1 IHC FFPE 10 % staining
Maahs 2007 Brazil 45 Oral cavity All pN 51 % CCND1 IHC FFPE 1 % staining
Rodolico 2005 Italy 97 Lower lip Any T cN0 pN 13 % CCND1 IHC FFPE 1 % staining
Miyamoto b 2003 Japan 41 Oral cavity All pN 20 % CCND1 IHC FFPE 10 % staining
Takes 2002 Netherlands 52 Oral cavity All pN 63 % CCND1 IHC FFPE 5 % staining
Goto 2002 Japan 41 Tongue cT1-2 pN 44 % CCND1 IHC FFPE 33 % staining
Kuo 1999 Taiwan 88 Oral cavity All pN 60 % CCND1 IHC FFPE 10 % staining
Bova 1999 Australia 147 Tongue All pN 23 % CCND1 IHC FFPE 10 % staining

TNM tumor-node-metastasis, FISH fluorescence in situ hybridization, CGH comparative genomic hybridization, IHC immunohistochemistry, FFPE formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded, FNA fine needle aspiration, G/C gene/chromosome

aHistologically proven nodal metastasis

bThese studies correlated both gene amplification and protein overexpression with nodal metastasis

cTPCN2, MYEOV, CCND1, ORAOV1, FGF4, TMEM16A, FADD, PPFIA1, CTTN, SHANK2, DHCR7