Ref (type) | Population | Outcome, Interventions | Results and statistical analysis | Effect size | Favours |
Adverse effects | |||||
RCT |
222 Vietnamese children, aged 1–15 years with dengue shock syndrome |
Fever and chills
0 children with crystalloid regimens (sodium chloride or Ringer’s lactate) 6 children with colloid regimens (dextran 70 or gelafundin) |
Significance not reported |
||
RCT |
222 Vietnamese children, aged 1–15 years with dengue shock syndrome |
Recurrence of shock
0 children with crystalloid regimens (sodium chloride or Ringer’s lactate) 2 children with colloid regimens (dextran 70 or gelafundin) |
Significance not reported A total of 35 children equally distributed among the four groups required diuretic treatment for 1 or 2 days after recovery from shock |
||
RCT |
222 Vietnamese children, aged 1–15 years with dengue shock syndrome |
Bleeding
0 children with crystalloid regimens (sodium chloride or Ringer’s lactate) 2 children with colloid regimens (dextran 70 or gelafundin) |
Significance not reported 1 child receiving gelafundin had severe epistaxis requiring transfusion, while 1 child receiving dextran developed a large haematoma at a site of minor trauma |
||
RCT 3-armed trial |
383 Vietnamese children aged 2–15 with moderately severe dengue shock syndrome (moderate severity: pulse pressure >10 mmHg and up to 20 mmHg) |
Allergic type reactions
0/128 (0%) with Ringer’s lactate (crystalloid regimen) 9/126 (7%) with 6% dextran 70 (colloid regimen) 1/129 (1%) with 6% hydroxyethyl starch (colloid regimen) |
Difference among groups P < 0.001 Of the additional 129 children in the RCT with severe shock, allergic reactions were reported in 6/67 [9%] with dextran v 0/62 [0%] with starch; P = 0.03 Overall in the RCT, 15 children receiving dextran had severe reactions (transient high fever and rigors without cardiorespiratory compromise) that occurred within 6 hours of infusing the study fluid, and 1 child in the starch group developed an urticarial rash without fever at the end of the infusion All children responded to symptomatic treatment alone, but 1 child died |