Table 1.
Comparison of Interventions Targeting Mental Health Self-Stigma
| Treatment Approach/Authors | Format | Peer or Professionally Run? | Languages | # of Sessions | Primary Mechanisms of Action | State of Data on Efficacy |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Healthy Self-Concept McCay et al. (2006; 2007) | Group | Professional | English | 12 | Psychoeducation, Support, Emphasis on Positive Attributes | Significant impact on self-stigma, hope and self-esteem from medium RCT |
| Self-Stigma Reduction Program Fung et al. (2011) | Group and Individual | Professional | MandarinChinese | 12 Group, 4 Individual | Psychoeducation, Cognitive Restructuring, Motivational Interview, Social Skills Training | Significant impact on self-esteem and treatment participation from small RCT |
| Ending Self-Stigma (ESS) Lucksted et al, (2011) | Group | Either | English | 9 | Psychoeducation, Cognitive Restructuring | Significant impact on self-stigma, recovery, perceived social support and self-esteem from uncontrolled pilot; Large RCT in progress |
| Narrative Enhancement and Cognitive Therapy (NECT) Yanos, Roe &Lysaker, (2011) Yanos et al., (2012) Roe et al. (2010; 2014) | Group | Professional | English; Hebrew; Russion; Swedish | 20 | Psycho-education, Cognitive Restructuring, Narrative Enhancement | Significant impact on self-stigma, hope, self-esteem and subjective quality of life from quasi-experimental study; non-significant impact from small RCT; Large RCT in progress |
| Coming Out Proud Corrigan et al. (2013); Rusch et al. (In Press) | Group | Peer | English, German | 3 | Discussion of pros and cons of disclosure; Telling one’s story | Significant impact on stigma stress, secrecy and disclosure stress from medium RCT |
| Anti-Stigma Photovoice Intervention Russinova et al. (2014) | Group | Peer | English | 10 | Psycho-education; Taking and sharing of photographs; writing narrative relating to photographs | Significant impact on self-stigma, coping with societal stigma, greater increase in a sense of community activism, and perceived recovery and growth from medium RCT |